Home Case Laws Writ dismissed as GST penalty under Section 129(3) was challenged belatedly without...

Writ dismissed as GST penalty under Section 129(3) was challenged belatedly without diligence, with liberty to pursue appeal under Section 14 of the Limitation Act.

0
240

Case Details

Case Title: HDB Financial Services Limited v. State of U.P. and Others
Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad (Chief Justice’s Court)
Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 2098 of 2024
Date of Judgment: 31 January 2025
Neutral Citation: 2025:AHC:14152-DB
Relevant Section: Section 129(3), CGST Act, 2017; Section 14, Limitation Act, 1963
Category of Dispute: Penalty under detention proceedings

Facts (Paras 1–2)

The petitioner, HDB Financial Services Limited, challenged an order dated 18.07.2024 imposing penalty of ₹5,40,000 under Section 129(3) of the GST Act. The goods in question—a Pokland machine—were being moved to the petitioner’s parking yard at Varanasi after the borrower defaulted on payments under an arbitration award. The goods were detained on 02.07.2024 and penalty was imposed. The petitioner claimed ownership on the basis of hypothecation and arbitration award, but such claim was rejected. The writ petition was filed on 21.10.2024.


Questions / Dispute (Paras 3–4)

The primary issue was whether movement of repossessed goods to a parking yard required an e-way bill and whether the penalty under Section 129(3) was valid. The petitioner argued that no e-way bill was needed since the movement was not a taxable supply. The respondents contended that this plea was an afterthought, noting the petitioner’s failure to raise the ownership claim within the available time and casual approach in filing the petition months later.


Observations (Paras 5–7)

The Court observed that the petitioner had an alternate remedy of appeal against the penalty order. By virtue of Section 14 of the Limitation Act, the delay in filing an appeal could be condoned considering pendency of writ. Importantly, the petitioner’s conduct undermined its case: despite having 15 days to assert ownership, no steps were taken. Even after passing of the order, only a cursory email titled “GST appeal” was sent on 06.09.2024, before finally filing the writ in October 2024.


Judgment (Paras 7–8)

The Court held that the writ petition could not be entertained under Article 226, as the petitioner’s assertions required factual investigation and its conduct did not inspire confidence. The petition was dismissed, leaving it open for the petitioner to pursue an appeal with the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act.


Case Law Table

Case Court Issue Verdict
HDB Financial Services Ltd. v. State of U.P. (2025:AHC:14152-DB) Allahabad HC Penalty under Section 129(3) for moving repossessed goods without e-way bill Writ dismissed; remedy of appeal available with limitation benefit under Sec. 14 of Limitation Act

Between Fine Lines

For businesses repossessing assets, this ruling underscores that movement of such goods may still invite detention under GST if e-way bill norms are not followed. Courts are unlikely to quash penalties on writ when an alternate appellate remedy exists, especially if the taxpayer’s conduct shows delay or casualness. The practical takeaway is: file a timely appeal rather than rely on writ jurisdiction.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY