Home Case Laws Writ dismissed as incompetent due to defective affidavit; liberty granted to refile...

Writ dismissed as incompetent due to defective affidavit; liberty granted to refile with proper authorization

0
207

Case Details

  • Court: Patna High Court

  • Case No.: CWJC No. 5125 of 2024

  • Petitioners: Maa Kamakhya Traders & Others

  • Respondents: Union of India & Others (Customs/DRI)

  • Date of Judgment: 17 March 2025

  • Relevant Sections: Section 110 & Section 108 of the Customs Act, 1962; Order XIX Rule 3 CPC

  • Category of Dispute: Seizure of goods and provisional release (Areca Nuts)

Facts (Paras 1–8)

Four petitioners, including two trading firms and a logistic company, challenged the seizure of 23,520 kgs. of areca nuts and a Tata LPT truck under Section 110 of the Customs Act, 1962, alleging violations of Sections 32, 33, 34, 46, and 47. They also sought provisional release of goods on account of perishability and quashing of summons issued under Section 108. The writ was supported by an affidavit sworn by Gopal Yadav, Manager-cum-Representative of Petitioner No. 3, without any declaration of authorization from the other petitioners.


Questions Before Court

  1. Whether the writ petition was maintainable when the affidavit was sworn by a person not expressly authorized by all petitioners?

  2. Whether the absence of proper authorization and defective affidavit rendered the writ application incompetent?


Observations (Paras 9–16)

  • The Court noted that petitioners 1 and 2 had interest in the seized goods, while petitioners 3 and 4 were concerned with the vehicle. However, no authorization was filed empowering the deponent to act for all petitioners.

  • The affidavit also did not state that the deponent had read and understood the writ petition, violating Order XIX Rule 3 CPC.

  • The Court relied upon Dipendra Nath Sarkar v. State of Bihar, AIR 1962 Pat 101 (Full Bench), which invalidated affidavits sworn without locus or clarity between knowledge and belief.

  • The Court further held that reliance on the earlier decision in Sukhdeo Singh v. Union of India (05.12.2024) was misplaced, since it ignored the binding Full Bench authority and was therefore per incuriam (Paras 13–15).

  • Following State of Bihar v. Kalika Kuer (2003) 5 SCC 448, the Court reiterated that ignoring binding precedent renders a judgment per incuriam.


Judgment (Paras 16–21)

  • The writ application was held to be incompetent for want of valid affidavit and authorization.

  • On request of petitioners, the writ was dismissed as withdrawn with liberty to file afresh with proper authorization and affidavit.

  • All contentions on merits of seizure were left open.


Table of Cases Referred

Case Citation Verdict/Ratio
Dipendra Nath Sarkar v. State of Bihar AIR 1962 Pat 101 (Full Bench) Affidavit defective if deponent has no locus or fails to distinguish statements of knowledge and belief; affidavit rejected.
Sukhdeo Singh v. Union of India CWJC No. 7999/2020, Patna HC (05.12.2024) Technical defect in affidavit treated as inadvertent mistake; however, later held per incuriam for ignoring Full Bench precedent.
State of Bihar v. Kalika Kuer @ Kalika Singh (2003) 5 SCC 448 Per incuriam arises when binding precedent/statute ignored; earlier judgment ignoring binding law is not good law.

Between Fine Lines

This ruling underscores that technical compliance in affidavits is not a mere formality but a jurisdictional necessity. For businesses challenging seizure of goods under Customs/GST, affidavits must be executed by properly authorized representatives, clearly stating authorization and basis of knowledge. Failure to comply can render the writ itself incompetent, irrespective of the merits of the dispute.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY