Case Details:
-
Case Title: M/s Rezaul Islam & Anr. vs State of Assam & Ors.
-
Court Name: Gauhati High Court
-
Petition Number: WP(C)/5539/2024
-
Relevant Section: Section 74 and Section 107 of the CGST/AGST Act, 2017; Rule 142 of CGST/AGST Rules
-
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit, Refund, Natural Justice
-
Date of Judgement: 12.11.2024
-
Relevant Provisions:
-
CGST/AGST Act, 2017: Sections 74, 107
-
CGST Rules: Rule 142
-
Facts of the Case [¶1–5]:
-
The petitioner, a registered proprietorship firm dealing in coal, challenged an Order-in-Original dated 16.08.2024 passed under Section 74 of the CGST/AGST Act for the period April 2022 to March 2023. [¶1]
-
The order raised a demand of ₹1,06,59,000 on account of alleged wrongful ITC and refund claims, particularly ₹45,16,525 refund sanctioned earlier. [¶3]
-
The SCN cited excess ITC claims, including from fake entities and cancelled registrations amounting to over ₹32 lakhs. [¶3]
-
Petitioner’s bank account was frozen from 05.04.2024 citing threat to revenue interest. [¶4]
-
Petitioner alleged denial of opportunity for hearing before final order was passed. [¶6]
Question(s) in Consideration [¶6–10]:
-
Whether the petitioner was denied natural justice in passing the order without affording opportunity of hearing?
-
Whether writ jurisdiction under Article 226 could be invoked despite availability of alternate remedy under Section 107?
-
Whether relief could be granted considering the petitioner’s frozen bank account prevented the statutory pre-deposit?
Observations of Court [¶9–13]:
-
Court reiterated the settled position that writ petition under Article 226 is not maintainable when adequate statutory remedies exist, unless exceptional grounds are made out. [¶9]
-
Receipt of SCN was admitted by petitioner; hence the plea of total denial of natural justice was not sustainable. Mere non-submission of reply does not constitute a ground of absolute denial of hearing. [¶11–12]
-
Section 107 provides full appellate remedy with timeline and pre-deposit conditions. Court noted no bar for petitioner to pursue appeal. [¶13–13.1]
Judgement of the Court [¶14–19]:
-
Writ petition dismissed as not maintainable due to availability of alternate appellate remedy under Section 107. [¶14]
-
However, petitioner permitted to file appeal without pre-deposit provided the frozen account has sufficient funds as per Section 107(6)(b). [¶18(i)]
-
If insufficient, petitioner may deposit additional amount before Appellate Authority. [¶18(ii)]
-
If freeze is lifted during appeal, petitioner must ensure pre-deposit to continue proceedings. [¶18(iii)]
Between Fine Lines:
-
The High Court reiterated that statutory remedy under Section 107 is the preferred recourse.
-
No violation of natural justice was found since SCN was served.
-
Petitioner can file appeal without pre-deposit if frozen account has equivalent funds.
-
Failure to meet deposit conditions can affect further appeal.
-
Relief was extended on parity with earlier similar case.
Summary of Referred Cases:
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thansingh Nathmal vs. Superintendent of Taxes | AIR 1964 SC 1419 | Established principle that writ not maintainable if alternative statutory remedy exists | Referred for principle of alternative remedy |
| WP(C) 4694/2024 | Gauhati High Court | Permitted appeal without pre-deposit if bank account was already frozen with sufficient funds | Relief extended similarly here |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




