Home Case Laws Writ Dismissed: GST Assessee Directed to Approach Appellate Authority

Writ Dismissed: GST Assessee Directed to Approach Appellate Authority

0
318

Case Details:

  • Case Title: M/s Rezaul Islam & Anr. vs State of Assam & Ors.

  • Court Name: Gauhati High Court

  • Petition Number: WP(C)/5539/2024

  • Relevant Section: Section 74 and Section 107 of the CGST/AGST Act, 2017; Rule 142 of CGST/AGST Rules

  • Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit, Refund, Natural Justice

  • Date of Judgement: 12.11.2024

  • Relevant Provisions:

    • CGST/AGST Act, 2017: Sections 74, 107

    • CGST Rules: Rule 142


Facts of the Case [¶1–5]:

  1. The petitioner, a registered proprietorship firm dealing in coal, challenged an Order-in-Original dated 16.08.2024 passed under Section 74 of the CGST/AGST Act for the period April 2022 to March 2023. [¶1]

  2. The order raised a demand of ₹1,06,59,000 on account of alleged wrongful ITC and refund claims, particularly ₹45,16,525 refund sanctioned earlier. [¶3]

  3. The SCN cited excess ITC claims, including from fake entities and cancelled registrations amounting to over ₹32 lakhs. [¶3]

  4. Petitioner’s bank account was frozen from 05.04.2024 citing threat to revenue interest. [¶4]

  5. Petitioner alleged denial of opportunity for hearing before final order was passed. [¶6]


Question(s) in Consideration [¶6–10]:

  1. Whether the petitioner was denied natural justice in passing the order without affording opportunity of hearing?

  2. Whether writ jurisdiction under Article 226 could be invoked despite availability of alternate remedy under Section 107?

  3. Whether relief could be granted considering the petitioner’s frozen bank account prevented the statutory pre-deposit?


Observations of Court [¶9–13]:

  1. Court reiterated the settled position that writ petition under Article 226 is not maintainable when adequate statutory remedies exist, unless exceptional grounds are made out. [¶9]

  2. Receipt of SCN was admitted by petitioner; hence the plea of total denial of natural justice was not sustainable. Mere non-submission of reply does not constitute a ground of absolute denial of hearing. [¶11–12]

  3. Section 107 provides full appellate remedy with timeline and pre-deposit conditions. Court noted no bar for petitioner to pursue appeal. [¶13–13.1]


Judgement of the Court [¶14–19]:

  1. Writ petition dismissed as not maintainable due to availability of alternate appellate remedy under Section 107. [¶14]

  2. However, petitioner permitted to file appeal without pre-deposit provided the frozen account has sufficient funds as per Section 107(6)(b). [¶18(i)]

  3. If insufficient, petitioner may deposit additional amount before Appellate Authority. [¶18(ii)]

  4. If freeze is lifted during appeal, petitioner must ensure pre-deposit to continue proceedings. [¶18(iii)]


Between Fine Lines:

  • The High Court reiterated that statutory remedy under Section 107 is the preferred recourse.

  • No violation of natural justice was found since SCN was served.

  • Petitioner can file appeal without pre-deposit if frozen account has equivalent funds.

  • Failure to meet deposit conditions can affect further appeal.

  • Relief was extended on parity with earlier similar case.


Summary of Referred Cases:

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Thansingh Nathmal vs. Superintendent of Taxes AIR 1964 SC 1419 Established principle that writ not maintainable if alternative statutory remedy exists Referred for principle of alternative remedy
WP(C) 4694/2024 Gauhati High Court Permitted appeal without pre-deposit if bank account was already frozen with sufficient funds Relief extended similarly here

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY