Case: M/s Hardwarilal and Sons Private Ltd. v. State of U.P. and Others
Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 2240 of 2025
Neutral Citation: 2025:AHC:82173-DB
Date of Judgment: 14.05.2025
Coram: Hon’ble Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and Hon’ble Justice Kshitij Shailendra
Category of Dispute: GST Demand under Section 74 – Jurisdictional validity of SCN and demand order
Relevant Sections: Section 74, Section 107 CGST/UPGST Act, 2017; Article 226 Constitution of India
Facts (Para 1–4)
The petitioner, M/s Hardwarilal and Sons Pvt. Ltd., challenged a show cause notice dated 05.12.2024 and a demand order dated 07.02.2025 issued under Section 74 of the UPGST Act, 2017 for FY 2018–19. It was argued that invocation of Section 74 required allegation of fraud, wilful misstatement, or suppression of facts, but the notice failed to establish such jurisdictional foundation. The petitioner also contended that despite demanding a copy of the SIB report on 13.01.2025, the same was not supplied, and their reply raising this issue was ignored in the final order. Reliance was placed on Raj Bahadur Narain Singh Sugar Mills Ltd. (1997) 6 SCC 81, Gopal Zarda Udyog (2005) 8 SCC 157, and Hel Infotech Ltd., Writ Tax No. 1396/2024.
Questions before Court
-
Whether the show cause notice issued under Section 74 lacked jurisdiction for not specifically alleging fraud, wilful misstatement, or suppression of facts.
-
Whether non-supply of the SIB report vitiated the adjudication order.
-
Whether the writ petition was maintainable in light of the appellate remedy under Section 107.
Observations (Para 8–12)
The Court observed that the SCN clearly alleged sale of iron scrap without any corresponding purchase, indicating evasion of tax. Such allegations, even if not reproducing the exact statutory terminology, fell within the ambit of fraud/suppression envisaged under Section 74. It was clarified that use of identical statutory words was not mandatory if the factual foundation pointed to fraud or suppression.
On the issue of the SIB report, the Court held that mere non-supply of a document does not vitiate adjudication unless prejudice is demonstrated. The petitioner’s reliance on precedents was found misplaced as those cases dealt with either absence of jurisdictional allegations or different issues like classification disputes.
Judgment (Para 13–15)
The Court dismissed the writ petition, holding that:
-
The SCN contained sufficient allegations to justify action under Section 74.
-
The petitioner had an adequate statutory remedy of appeal under Section 107 of the Act.
-
The extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 was not to be exercised when alternate remedies exist.
It was clarified that none of the Court’s observations would prejudice the petitioner in pursuing appellate remedies.
Table of Cases Referred
| Case | Citation | Verdict / Principle |
|---|---|---|
| Raj Bahadur Narain Singh Sugar Mills Ltd. v. Union of India | (1997) 6 SCC 81 | SCN quashed as it failed to allege acts of commission/omission under Rule 10 CE Rules, 1944. |
| Gopal Zarda Udyog v. CCE | (2005) 8 SCC 157 | Concerned with classification dispute; not applicable here. |
| Hel Infotech Ltd. v. CCT | Writ Tax No. 1396/2024 (Allahabad HC, 27.09.2024) | SCN quashed as it failed to spell out fraud/suppression allegations; distinguished in present case. |
Between Fine Lines
This judgment reiterates that a GST show cause notice need not mechanically reproduce statutory words like “fraud” or “suppression” if factual allegations substantively point towards evasion. Taxpayers cannot bypass the appellate route under Section 107 by directly invoking writ jurisdiction unless there is a glaring lack of jurisdiction. The ruling underscores that disputes on sufficiency of evidence, such as non-supply of certain reports, are best addressed before appellate forums.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




