Home Case Laws Writ petition dismissed as officer under KGST Act held competent under IGST;...

Writ petition dismissed as officer under KGST Act held competent under IGST; petitioner directed to file appeal under Section 107 KGST

0
317

Case Title: SLM Stationery v. Union of India & Ors
Court: High Court of Karnataka, Dharwad Bench
Petition No.: Writ Petition No.100038 of 2025 (T-RES)
Date of Judgment: 05 March 2025
Relevant Sections: Section 4, IGST Act, 2017; Section 6, CGST/KGST Acts; Section 107, KGST Act; Section 20, IGST Act
Category: Jurisdiction / Confiscation / Alternative Remedy


Facts (Paras 2–4):

The petitioner, a Kerala-based proprietorship (SLM Stationery), transported arecanut to Delhi through Karnataka. The goods were intercepted by the Commercial Tax Officer (Enforcement-2, Vijayapura) for absence of e-way bill. Despite the petitioner’s claim of network failure and submission of documents, the goods were detained and subsequently confiscated under Section 130 of the KGST/CGST Act read with IGST Act. An auction notice followed, leading to this writ petition challenging the confiscation and jurisdiction of the officer.


Questions Before Court (Paras 5–8):

  1. Whether the State Tax Officer under Section 6 of the KGST could act as a “proper officer” under Section 4 of the IGST Act without a specific Central notification?

  2. Whether the confiscation order was without jurisdiction, and if the petitioner had an alternative appellate remedy under Section 107 KGST/Section 20 IGST?


Observations (Paras 9–22):

The Court examined Section 4 of the IGST Act and Section 6 of the CGST/KGST Acts. It noted that these provisions inherently provide cross-empowerment of State and Central officers, unless exceptions are notified by the Government of India. Since no such exception notification exists, officers appointed under Section 6 of KGST automatically qualify as “proper officers” under IGST.
Citing judgments from various High Courts — Sodhi Cargo Movers (P&H), Advantage India Logistics (MP), Bright Road Logistics (P&H), Narayan Sahu (Orissa), Pinnacle Vehicles (Kerala) — the Court confirmed that cross-empowerment is the rule, and notification is only needed for imposing exceptions.


Judgment (Paras 23–36):

  • The fourth respondent (Commercial Tax Officer), being an authorized officer under Section 6 KGST, was held to be the proper officer under Section 4 IGST.

  • The Court held that a confiscation order under Section 130 is appealable under Section 107 KGST read with Section 20 IGST, citing Falcon Enterprises v. State of Gujarat (SC), Commercial Steel Ltd. (SC), Kesar Farm v. Addl. Commissioner (Karnataka DB), and Rajalakshmi Enterprises v. Addl. Chief Secretary (Karnataka SB).

  • The writ petition was dismissed, directing the petitioner to file an appeal within four weeks, and restraining the authorities from auctioning the goods until the appellate decision.


Between Fine Lines (Trade Takeaway):

This judgment clarifies that State GST enforcement officers are validly empowered to act under IGST for inter-State transactions unless specifically restricted by notification. Any confiscation or penalty order passed by such officers must be challenged through the statutory appellate route under Section 107, not through writ petitions. The decision reinforces the cross-empowerment doctrine under GST and limits High Court interference where alternate remedies exist.


Table – Cases Referred and Outcomes

Case Name Court / Citation Principle / Outcome
TVL. Vardhan Infrastructures v. Head of GST Council Secretariat (2024) 125 GSTR 334 Madras HC Held lack of cross-empowerment notification renders action invalid (not followed here).
Sodhi Cargo Movers (P) Ltd. v. State of Haryana (2023 SCC OnLine P&H 3949) Punjab & Haryana HC State officers cross-empowered under IGST; upheld jurisdiction.
Advantage India Logistics (P) Ltd. v. UOI (2018) 58 GSTR 247 Madhya Pradesh HC Notification under Sec.4 IGST not mandatory; State officers competent.
Bright Road Logistics v. State (2023 SCC OnLine P&H 4242) Punjab & Haryana HC Assistant Excise Officer held “proper officer” under IGST.
Narayan Sahu v. UOI (W.P.(C) 28012/2024) Orissa HC Cross-authorization automatic unless limited by notification.
Pinnacle Vehicles & Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Joint Commissioner (2025 SCC OnLine Ker 231) Kerala HC (DB) Confirmed inherent cross-empowerment under Sec.6 CGST.
Falcon Enterprises v. State of Gujarat SLP (C) 6923/2021 Supreme Court Appeal under Sec.107 CGST is proper remedy against confiscation.
Commr. of State Tax v. Commercial Steel Ltd. (2022) 16 SCC 447 Supreme Court Writ not maintainable when alternate statutory remedy exists.
Kesar Farm v. Addl. Commissioner (W.A. 3974/2019) Karnataka DB Appeal under Sec.107 available against orders u/s 129 & 130.
Rajalakshmi Enterprises v. Addl. Chief Secretary (W.P. 12554/2020) Karnataka SB Writ dismissed; appeal under Sec.107 is proper remedy.
K.B. Processing & Trading v. Joint Commissioner (W.P. 105711/2023) Karnataka SB Officer under State GST empowered under IGST; appeal lies under Sec.107.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY