Case Summary
Case Title, Court, Petition No., Date & Category
Association of Power Producers v. Solar Energy Corporation of India Ltd. & Ors.
High Court of Delhi
W.P.(C) 12511/2024 & CM APPL. 51976/2024
Date of Judgment: 10.09.2024
Category: Levy of GST / Clarification on Taxability of Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS)
Relevant Statutory Provisions: Sections 9, 11, 168 of the CGST Act, 2017, corresponding SGST Act, and IGST Act, 2017.
FACTS (Paras 1–9)
The petitioner, an industry association representing power producers, filed the writ petition seeking directions compelling SECI and the Ministry of Power to issue clarifications on GST applicability to Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) in respect of an RfS dated 26.06.2024, which required bidders to quote tariffs exclusive of GST . The petitioner further sought directions to CBIC to issue a clarification on GST levy on BESS services.
The petitioner argued that clause 30.2(III)(e) of the RfS creates uncertainty because GST liability affects entitlement to input tax credit, affecting bid pricing by nearly 20%. Ambiguity allegedly arose following issuance of Draft PSP Guidelines (22.08.2024), which stated that GST is leviable on storage services of pumped-storage plants. The petitioner contended that but for these draft guidelines, there was no ambiguity in GST applicability .
SECI opposed the petition as belated, noting that pre-bid meeting was held on 12.07.2024, bids submitted on 12.08.2024, and the petitioner approached the Court one day before bid opening (11.09.2024). SECI also argued that the draft PSP guidelines were irrelevant and not applicable to BESS RfS .
QUESTIONS OF LAW (Derived from Paras 10–17)
-
Whether CBIC can be compelled, under Section 168 of the CGST Act, to issue clarifications on GST applicability to specific transactions upon request of private parties.
-
Whether SECI or the Ministry of Power can be directed to issue binding GST clarifications impacting bidding process for BESS services.
-
Whether the Court should intervene days before bid opening to address purported ambiguities not raised at the pre-bid stage.
OBSERVATIONS OF THE COURT (Paras 11–17)
The Court held that GST liability arises strictly under the CGST/SGST/IGST Acts and corresponding rules, and any issue of taxability must be determined by bidders with reference to these statutes. There is no statutory duty on CBIC to respond to individual taxpayer queries. Section 168 empowers CBIC to issue instructions for uniform implementation but does not require the Board to issue clarifications on demand by taxpayers .
The Court also noted that the RfS clause is unambiguous: bids must be quoted exclusive of GST, and GST, “if any,” would be passed through to the buying entity. Thus, no contractual ambiguity exists requiring judicial intervention.
The Court found merit in SECI’s argument that the petition was highly delayed, as all issues should have been raised in the pre-bid meeting of 12.07.2024. The petitioner’s reliance on Draft PSP Guidelines was misplaced since these draft guidelines had no application to the BESS RfS.
JUDGMENT / VERDICT (Paras 17–19)
The Court refused to issue any directions to SECI, Ministry of Power, or CBIC. It held that:
-
CBIC cannot be compelled to issue GST clarifications to taxpayers.
-
SECI cannot issue binding clarifications on GST applicability under the CGST Act.
-
Bidders must independently ascertain GST liability under applicable statutes.
-
The writ petition was belated and without merit.
Accordingly, the writ petition and pending application were dismissed .
SUMMARY OF CASES REFERRED (Table Form)
(Note: The judgment itself does not refer to any external case law; accordingly the table reflects this.)
| Case Referred | Court | Issue | Verdict | Relevance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nil | – | – | – | The judgment relies solely on statutory interpretation; no precedent cited. |
BETWEEN FINE LINES (Practical Trade Takeaways)
The Court clarified that GST ambiguity cannot be resolved through judicial directions to CBIC or SECI. Bidders participating in energy-sector RfS processes must conduct independent taxability assessments using GST law and cannot expect the procuring entity or the tax authority to provide transaction-specific clarifications. Draft policy documents (like PSP guidelines) do not modify taxability unless incorporated into statutory framework. Last-minute litigation on tender terms is strongly discouraged.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”



