Case Summary: Swastik Plastics v. Commissioner of DGST
W.P.(C) 5680/2022 | Delhi High Court | Decision dated 26.09.2022**
Relevant Provisions:
Section 74, Delhi GST Act, 2017; Guidelines for Inspection/Search/Seizure dated 01.12.2020 as modified vide Circular dated 20.09.2022.
Category of Dispute:
Jurisdictional invalidity of adjudication — bias due to same officer conducting search and adjudication
Facts (with Para References)
The petitioner challenged the order dated 11.03.2022 issued under Section 74 DGST Act by the Assistant Commissioner. As recorded in para 3 of the Court’s order dated 05.04.2022, the petitioner demonstrated that Mr. Chunni Lal Roy, who issued the adjudication order, was also the officer who conducted investigation, search and seizure at the petitioner’s premises (page 51 of the record). The search authorization dated 23.08.2021 clearly showed his involvement. The Court noted these facts and observed that such dual roles raise grave concerns of institutional bias (para 6).
Questions Before the Court (with Para References)
Whether an adjudication order under Section 74 DGST Act is vitiated when the same officer who conducts search and seizure also proceeds to adjudicate, thereby creating a likelihood of bias, especially in light of the later-issued Guidelines dated 20.09.2022 (paras 3–6).
Court’s Observations (with Para References)
The Court observed (para 6) that prima facie there exists a “likelihood of bias” when the same official is empowered both to conduct intrusive enforcement actions (search/seizure) and to sit in adjudication. The Court took judicial notice of the new Circular dated 20.09.2022, produced by the revenue (paras 5–5.1), titled “Modification of Guidelines for Tax Authorities for Inspection, Search and Seizure dated 01.12.2020”, which laid down revised administrative safeguards. Importantly, the Court recognized that the petitioner had raised the jurisdictional objection at the very outset (para 6), and that the updated guidelines required re-alignment of departmental conduct for fairness and impartiality.
Judgment / Verdict (with Para References)
The Court held (para 7) that the impugned order dated 11.03.2022 stands set aside. It directed that fresh de novo proceedings must commence strictly in accordance with the modified Guidelines of 20.09.2022 (paras 6.1 & 7.1), meaning that the adjudicating officer must not be the same as the officer who conducted search and seizure. The Court clarified that a fresh show cause notice must be issued to the petitioner, adhering to the revised procedural safeguards. The writ petition was accordingly disposed of, and all pending applications stood closed (paras 8–9).
Between Fine Lines — Practical Takeaways for Trade
This ruling reinforces that GST adjudication must be institutionally impartial: the officer who investigates cannot adjudicate. Any order passed by such an officer is liable to be struck down. Taxpayers should vigilantly check search/seizure authorization records and ensure that adjudication is conducted by an independent authority, especially after the 20.09.2022 Circular which mandates functional separation of investigation and adjudication wings.
Case Law Referred — Summary Table
| Case Referred | Court’s Usage in Judgment | Verdict Summary |
|---|---|---|
| No external cases referred in this judgment | The judgment is entirely based on internal reasoning and the updated Circular dated 20.09.2022. | — |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




