Home Case Laws Pre-26.07.2023 SUV Ground Clearance Under Entry 52B Measured Laden; Unladen Explanation Prospective;...

Pre-26.07.2023 SUV Ground Clearance Under Entry 52B Measured Laden; Unladen Explanation Prospective; Website Data Cannot Override ARAI Certificates: GSTAT Bengaluru

0
32

1. Title of the Case

Case Title M/s Advaith Motors Private Limited v. The Commissioner of Central GST, Bengaluru South Commissionerate
Case Number Appeal No. APL/71/BUR/2026 (appeal dated 30.03.2026), against Order-in-Appeal No. 06/2024-25 COMMR-APPEALS-1 dated 25.04.2024 of the Commissioner (Appeals-I), Central Tax, Bengaluru, arising from Order-in-Original No. 10/2023-24 (GST-ADC) dated 19.12.2023 of the Additional Commissioner of Central Tax, Bengaluru South Commissionerate
Court and Bench Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal, Bengaluru Bench, Division Bench – Court No. 3; Coram: Shri Prabhakaran P.M., Judicial Member, and Shri Ravi Jesuraj S., Technical Member (State) (order authored by the Technical Member for the Bench)
Date of Order 27.10.2026 (pronounced in open Tribunal)
Relevant Provisions Sections 50(1), 59, 70(1), 73(1) and (9), 103(1), 112(1), 145 and 168(1) of the CGST Act, 2017; Sections 8 and 11(1) of the Goods and Services Tax (Compensation to States) Act, 2017; Entries 52A and 52B of Notification No. 01/2017-Compensation Cess (Rate) dated 28.06.2017, as inserted by Notification No. 05/2017-Compensation Cess (Rate) dated 11.09.2017 and substituted by Notification No. 03/2023-Compensation Cess (Rate) dated 26.07.2023; Circular No. 189/01/2023-GST dated 13.01.2023; Circular No. 247/04/2025-GST dated 14.02.2025; Rule 126 of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989; Clause 5.8 of IS 9435:2004

2. Summary of the Judgment

Facts of the Case: The appellant, an authorised Hyundai dealer in Bengaluru, sold Creta 1.6L, Tucson 2.0L and Alcazar 2.0L vehicles charging Compensation Cess at 20% under Entry 52A, the rate at which the manufacturer had billed it (paras 2, 5). A show cause notice dated 22.09.2023 under Section 73(1), covering 11.09.2017 to 31.07.2023, alleged that the vehicles were SUVs under Entry 52B (22%) because their unladen ground clearance, taken from the Hyundai South Africa website and Indian automobile portals, was 170 mm or more (paras 10-11). The ARAI certificates recorded laden ground clearance of 165 mm, 135 mm and 154 mm (para 11). The Order-in-Original confirmed differential cess of ₹9,76,21,566, interest and a penalty of ₹97,62,157 under Section 73(9); the first appeal was dismissed on 25.04.2024 (paras 14-15).

Issues for Determination: The Tribunal framed four issues (para 68): whether, for supplies before 26.07.2023, ground clearance under Entry 52B was to be measured laden or unladen; whether the Revenue proved ground clearance of 170 mm and above; whether the dealer could rely on the manufacturer’s rate; and whether the demand, interest and penalty could survive.

Findings and Observations of the Court: Until July 2023 the entry did not define ground clearance. Being a technical term, it takes the meaning fixed by the type-approval standard, and Clause 5.8 of IS 9435:2004 measures it on a fully laden vehicle (paras 71-73). Any doubt in a charging entry goes to the taxpayer, following Dilip Kumar (para 77). Notification No. 03/2023 substituted the entry and enlarged the levy, so it is prospective; Circular No. 247/04/2025-GST, which binds the Revenue, says so, as do the Bombay and Kerala High Courts in Mercedes-Benz and Popular Motor World (paras 78-87). On evidence, the burden of classification lies on the Revenue. Unverified website figures for vehicles made for another market cannot outweigh statutory ARAI certificates, and the Revenue never summoned the manufacturer or ARAI under Section 70 (paras 90-95). The plea that the dealer merely followed the manufacturer’s rate was rejected, since Section 59 obliges every supplier to self-assess (para 97).

Verdict and Basis of the Judgment: The appeal was allowed. Both orders were set aside, with the entire demand of ₹9,76,21,566, the interest under Section 50 and the penalty, because the vehicles fell under Entry 52A during the disputed period and no short payment was shown for supplies from 26.07.2023 (paras 98-103).

Analysis of the Judgment: The Tribunal reached the laden measure on its own reasoning and treated the High Court rulings as persuasive, leaving open whether a non-jurisdictional High Court binds it (para 87). Its insistence on testable evidence where the rate turns on a physical measurement is of wider use in classification disputes (para 95).

Legal Takeaway: Dealers facing 22% cess demands for supplies before 26.07.2023 should rely on ARAI certificates, IS 9435 and Circular No. 247/04/2025-GST. From that date, unladen ground clearance governs. Following the manufacturer’s classification shows good faith but is no defence in law.

3. Tabular Summary

Sl. No. Case Title Case No. / Citation Court / Bench Date of Order Facts & Issue Verdict & Basis of Judgment Key Legal Takeaway
1 M/s Advaith Motors Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central GST, Bengaluru South Commissionerate APL/71/BUR/2026; against OIA No. 06/2024-25 COMMR-APPEALS-1 dt. 25.04.2024 and OIO No. 10/2023-24 (GST-ADC) dt. 19.12.2023 GSTAT, Bengaluru Bench, DB – Court No. 3 (Prabhakaran P.M., JM; Ravi Jesuraj S., TM (State)) 27.10.2026 Hyundai dealer charged 20% Compensation Cess (Entry 52A) on Creta 1.6L, Tucson 2.0L and Alcazar 2.0L from 11.09.2017 to 31.07.2023. Revenue demanded 22% under Entry 52B, taking unladen ground clearance from a foreign website and portals; ARAI laden figures were 165, 135 and 154 mm. Cess of ₹9,76,21,566, interest and penalty of ₹97,62,157 confirmed. Issue: laden or unladen measure before 26.07.2023, and whether Revenue proved 170 mm. Appeal allowed; OIA and OIO set aside; demand, S. 50 interest and S. 73(9) penalty set aside. Undefined technical term takes the IS 9435 (laden) meaning; doubt in a charging entry favours the taxpayer; Notification 03/2023 is prospective and Circular 247/04/2025-GST binds the Revenue; Mercedes-Benz (Bom.) adopted as persuasive, Popular Motor World (Ker.) to the same effect. Burden on Revenue; website data cannot override ARAI certificates. For supplies before 26.07.2023, ground clearance under Entry 52B is the laden (ARAI) figure; the unladen Explanation applies only from that date. Revenue must prove a physical measurement by testable evidence. Manufacturer’s rate shows good faith but is no defence; a dealer must self-assess under S. 59.

Download the judgment: Download PDF | View online

LEAVE A REPLY