Home Case Laws Corporate Guarantee for Related Person Taxable Without Consideration; Rule 28(2) Read Down,...

Corporate Guarantee for Related Person Taxable Without Consideration; Rule 28(2) Read Down, 1% Deemed Value Yields to Lower Open Market Value: Delhi High Court

0
7

1. Title of the Case

Case Title Sterlite Power Transmission Limited & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors., with fifteen connected writ petitions filed by ReNew Private Limited, Jindal Stainless Hisar Limited (now merged with Jindal Stainless Limited), Azure Power India Pvt. Ltd., Nambi Buildwell Limited, JITF Urban Infrastructure Services Ltd., Essar Power Limited, GAIL India Limited, Essar Shipping Limited, Avaada Energy Pvt. Ltd. & Ors., SAEL Limited & Anr., Future Brands Limited, ISP Technologies Private Limited, Logix Realtors Private Limited, Hero Future Energies Pvt. Ltd. and Hero Solar Energy Private Limited
Case Number W.P.(C) 2966/2024 with CM APPL. 12196/2024 (lead matter; CNR No. DLHC010095132024), and connected W.P.(C) 10924/2024, 14622/2024, 15738/2024, 17559/2024, 12955/2025, 13341/2025, 13358/2025, 19506/2025, 214/2025, 5238/2025, 6436/2025, 7639/2025, 8990/2025, 280/2026 and 281/2026. No neutral citation appears on the copy of the judgment.
Court and Bench High Court of Delhi at New Delhi, Division Bench. Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bharat Parashar (judgment authored by Anil Kshetarpal, J.)
Date of Order Judgment reserved on 27.10.2026; pronounced and uploaded on 17.11.2026
Relevant Provisions CGST Act, 2017: Sections 2(17), 2(31), 2(33), 2(93)(c), 2(101), 2(102), 7(1)(c), 7(1A), 7(2)(a), 9, 13(2), 15(1), 15(4), 15(5), 31(2), 34, 148, 164 and 168; Entry 2 of Schedule I, Entry 5(e) of Schedule II and Entry 6 of Schedule III. CGST Rules, 2017: Rules 28(1), 28(2), 30, 31, 35 and 47. Notification No. 52/2023-Central Tax dated 26.10.2023; Notification No. 12/2024 dated 10.07.2024; Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST dated 27.10.2023; Circular No. 225/19/2024-GST dated 11.07.2024. Constitution of India: Articles 14, 19(1)(g), 246A, 265, 366(12A) and 366(26A). Indian Contract Act, 1872: Sections 126, 127, 140 and 145.

2. Summary of the Judgment

Facts of the Case: Sixteen writ petitions, led by Sterlite Power Transmission Limited, were filed by holding and group companies that had furnished corporate guarantees to lenders for their subsidiaries’ borrowings, without fee or commission (paras 1, 11.1 and 71). They challenged the GST levy, Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules (inserted by Notification No. 52/2023-Central Tax and amended by Notification No. 12/2024) and Circulars No. 204/16/2023-GST and 225/19/2024-GST (paras 2 and 3). Some deeds pre-dated 01.07.2017 (para 15.3).

Issues for Determination: Five issues were framed (para 40): whether a gratuitous guarantee for a related person is a supply of services and who receives it; whether it is excluded as an actionable claim or a security; whether Rule 28(2) is valid; when the supply takes place; and whether the Circulars are ultra vires Section 168.

Findings and Observations of the Court: By extending its creditworthiness and assuming the risk of the subsidiary’s default, the guarantor renders a service under Section 2(102) in the course of business; Entry 2 of Schedule I dispenses only with consideration (paras 50, 51, 67 and 71). The subsidiary is the recipient under Section 2(93)(c) (para 64). It receives credit support, not an actionable claim, and a guarantee is not a security (paras 74 and 77). Rule 28(2) is within Sections 15 and 164, but a deemed value operating as a fixed minimum is arbitrary (paras 78, 85 and 91). The supply is complete on execution and is not a continuous supply (paras 92 and 93).

Verdict and Basis of the Judgment: The petitions were partly allowed (para 131). Rule 28(2) was read down: the deemed value of 1% per annum is a rebuttable presumption that yields to a lower open market value proved by the supplier on cogent material; the price agreed within the group is not such material (paras 87 and 124). Pre-01.07.2017 guarantees are not taxable unless renewed, extended or enhanced; those of 01.07.2017 to 25.10.2023 are taxable but valued under the Rules then in force, without the 1% figure; Rule 28(2) applies only from 26.10.2023 (para 126). Contrary notices and demands were set aside for fresh determination (para 128).

Analysis of the Judgment: The Court agreed with the Gujarat High Court in Torrent Power on taxability but differed on five aspects, including annual recurrence of the taxable event, and declined to follow the Bombay High Court in D.P. Jain (paras 114, 116 and 117). Tax is computed on execution for the entire tenure; a Section 34 credit note is available on early release, and the Government may permit annual instalments (paras 96 to 100).

Legal Takeaway: Groups should list every guarantee by its date of execution, renewal, extension or enhancement, since that date decides taxability and valuation. From 26.10.2023, the value is 1% per annum for the whole tenure unless a lower open market value is proved; where the recipient has full input tax credit, the invoice value is accepted (para 89). Limitation under Section 74 remains open (para 129).

3. Tabular Summary

Sl. No. Case Title Case No. / Citation Court / Bench Date of Order Facts & Issue Verdict & Basis of Judgment Key Legal Takeaway
1 Sterlite Power Transmission Limited & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. (and connected matters) W.P.(C) 2966/2024 with CM APPL. 12196/2024, and fifteen connected writ petitions Delhi High Court (Division Bench): Anil Kshetarpal and Bharat Parashar, JJ. 17.11.2026 (reserved on 27.10.2026) Holding and group companies gave corporate guarantees to lenders for the borrowings of their subsidiaries without consideration. They challenged the GST levy, Rule 28(2), Notifications No. 52/2023 and 12/2024 and Circulars No. 204/16/2023-GST and 225/19/2024-GST. Issue: whether such a guarantee is a taxable supply, and how and when it is to be valued. Partly allowed. The guarantee is a supply of services under S. 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I; the subsidiary is the recipient; it is neither an actionable claim nor a security. Rule 28(2) is intra vires but read down: 1% per annum is a rebuttable presumption that yields to a lower open market value proved by the supplier. Single supply on execution, with time of supply under S. 13(2)(a) or (b); pre-GST guarantees not taxable unless renewed, extended or enhanced; guarantees of 01.07.2017 to 25.10.2023 valued under the Rules then in force; Rule 28(2) applies from 26.10.2023. Circulars valid but to be read with the judgment. Notices set aside to that extent for fresh determination. A corporate guarantee for a related person is taxable once, on execution (and on each renewal, extension or enhancement). The 1% deemed value can be displaced only by a lower open market value proved by the supplier, not by the intra-group price.

Download the judgment: Download PDF | View online

LEAVE A REPLY