Home Updates GST Interest Cannot Run After Tax Is Deposited in Electronic Cash Ledger:...

GST Interest Cannot Run After Tax Is Deposited in Electronic Cash Ledger: Gujarat High Court

0
130

In Anas Enterprise v. Union of India & Anr., R/Special Civil Application No. 11064 of 2025, the Gujarat High Court examined whether interest under Section 50 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 could continue to be levied merely because GST returns were filed belatedly, even though the corresponding tax amount had already been deposited in the Electronic Cash Ledger. The judgment was delivered on 16 July 2026 by a Division Bench comprising Justice A.S. Supehia and Justice Vaibhavi D. Nanavati.

Background of the Case

The petitioner, engaged in the manufacture and sale of chewing tobacco, had filed delayed GST returns for certain tax periods covering July–September 2017, June 2020 and March–June 2021. According to the judgment, the tax amounts relating to these returns had been deposited in the Electronic Cash Ledger before the respective due dates for filing returns, except in relation to April 2021.

Following an audit objection, the petitioner paid interest through FORM GST DRC-03 on 1 June 2023. Subsequently, a demand notice dated 17 January 2025 was issued concerning interest arising from delayed filing of returns. The petitioner relied upon the Gujarat High Court’s earlier decision in Arya Cotton Industries and Anr. v. Union of India and Anr., (2024) 130 GSTR 81, and applied for refund of the alleged excess interest paid.

The refund application was, however, rejected through FORM GST-RFD-06 dated 17 June 2025 principally on the ground that the proviso subsequently inserted in Rule 88B of the CGST Rules was prospective and could not be applied to earlier tax periods.

Core Legal Issue

The principal issue before the High Court was whether the refund of excess interest could be denied merely because the proviso to Rule 88B of the CGST Rules, inserted with effect from 10 July 2024, was considered prospective, when the petitioner’s claim was otherwise covered by the principles already laid down by the High Court in Arya Cotton Industries.

Gujarat High Court’s Findings

The Court reiterated the reasoning in Arya Cotton Industries that once money is deposited into the Electronic Cash Ledger, the amount assumes the character of tax money available for discharge of the taxpayer’s liability. Debiting the Electronic Cash Ledger at the time of filing the return is essentially an adjustment of the amount already deposited.

Accordingly, interest being compensatory in nature cannot ordinarily continue to be charged for a period during which the Government already has the corresponding amount available in the Electronic Cash Ledger. The earlier judgment had held that interest could be levied from the due date for payment of tax only until the date on which such tax was deposited into the Electronic Cash Ledger, rather than continuing until the date of filing the delayed return.

The High Court also noted that following the Arya Cotton Industries judgment dated 14 June 2024, the issue was considered at the 53rd GST Council meeting held on 22 June 2024, and the proviso to Rule 88B was thereafter inserted through Notification No. 12/2024 dated 10 July 2024.

The proviso addresses cases where an amount had been credited to the Electronic Cash Ledger on or before the due date for filing the return but was debited for tax payment when the return was subsequently filed after the due date. Such amount is not to be considered for calculating interest where it remained in the ledger from the due date until its debit.

Prospective Amendment Could Not Defeat Existing Judicial Ratio

A significant aspect of the judgment is the Court’s rejection of the department’s reasoning that the petitioner’s refund could be denied simply because the amendment to Rule 88B operated prospectively.

The Court observed that the authorities had not denied that the petitioner’s case was covered by the ratio of Arya Cotton Industries. Despite this, they declined the refund by relying upon their view regarding the prospective operation of the newly inserted proviso.

The Division Bench described this approach as a “classic case of selective denial” and held that the refund application ought to have been examined in light of the earlier judgment rather than rejected merely on the basis of the effective date of the Rule 88B amendment. The rejection order was held to be arbitrary and to suffer from non-application of mind.

Verdict

The Gujarat High Court allowed the writ petition and quashed both the refund rejection order dated 17 June 2025 and the recovery notice dated 17 January 2025.

The respondents were directed to grant refund of the excess interest in accordance with the petitioner’s refund application together with statutory interest at 6% per annum. The refund was directed to be processed within six weeks. In case of failure to comply within that period, the Court directed that the amount would carry further interest at 12% per annum for the delay.

The High Court also imposed costs of ₹5,000 on the respondent, to be deposited with the Registry within one week from receipt of the order.

Key Takeaway

The judgment reinforces the principle that interest under Section 50 is compensatory rather than penal in character. Where the required tax amount has already been deposited and remained available in the Electronic Cash Ledger, interest cannot be mechanically calculated until the later date on which a delayed return is filed merely because the ledger is formally debited on that date.

It also makes clear that an authority cannot disregard an applicable judicial precedent merely by relying upon the prospective effective date of a subsequent rule amendment where the legal principle governing the taxpayer’s claim had already been judicially recognised.

Download

LEAVE A REPLY