Home Case Laws Appeal can be made by consignee, if goods in transit were confiscated...

Appeal can be made by consignee, if goods in transit were confiscated by officers and order under Section 129(3) is issued against the driver of conveyance.

0
475

Case Title: Mehndihasan Rahemtulla Hariyani v. Deputy Commissioner of Revenue, Bureau of Investigation (North Bengal)

Court: High Court of Calcutta

Petition No.: W.P.A. No. 927 of 2022

Date of Judgement: November 3, 2022

Relevant Section: Section 129(3), Section 107 of the West Bengal Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017

Category of Dispute: Appeal Rights under GST

 

Facts of the Case

[¶1] The Deputy Commissioner of Revenue initiated proceedings under Section 129 of the WBGST Act, 2017 against Ashwani Sharma, the driver/person-in-charge of a vehicle, for transporting goods without proper documents.
[¶2] After adjudication, a tax and penalty of ₹1,45,320 each was imposed under Section 129(3) of the Act on the said driver.
[¶3] M/s Akash Trading Co., a proprietorship concern of the petitioner and the consignee of the goods, filed an appeal under Section 107 of the WBGST Act against the adjudication order.
[¶4] The appellate authority rejected the appeal on the ground that the order was passed against the driver and not the petitioner (consignee), hence the latter lacked locus standi to appeal.

 

Question(s) in Consideration

[¶4, ¶5] Whether the consignee of the goods, who was not a party to the original adjudication proceedings under Section 129, has the right to appeal under Section 107 of the WBGST Act, 2017?

 

Observation of Court

[¶6] The Court emphasized that Section 107 permits “any person aggrieved” by an order passed under the Act to file an appeal, and this includes consignees.
[¶7] Even though the adjudication was against the driver, the petitioner, being the consignee, was clearly aggrieved and had the right to challenge the same.
[¶8] The denial of appellate remedy on the ground of locus standi was unjustified and not legally tenable.

Judgement of the Court

[¶8] The impugned order dated October 27, 2021, of the appellate authority was set aside.
[¶8] The appellate authority was directed to hear and dispose of the appeal filed by the petitioner within one month of receiving this order.
[¶9] Writ petition WPA 927 of 2022 was disposed of accordingly.

 

Between Fine Lines

The High Court of Calcutta ruled that a consignee of detained goods has the right to appeal an adjudication order even if such an order was passed only against the vehicle driver. The term “any person aggrieved” in Section 107 was interpreted liberally to uphold the right to a remedy. This widens the appeal scope in GST disputes. The court reaffirmed the inclusive appellate right of consignees and clarified that denial on locus standi grounds is not valid.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

(No specific prior case law citations were mentioned or relied upon in the judgement.)

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
None cited – – –

 

Takeaway of the Case

“Consignee’s Right to Appeal: Not Just the Driver’s Burden”

LEAVE A REPLY