Case Title: Himalaya Drug Co. vs. Commissioner of Central Tax (Appeals-II)
Court: High Court of Karnataka
Petition Number: Writ Petition No. 10142 of 2021 (T-TAR)
Relevant Section: Article 226 of the Constitution of India; Section 107(1) & (4) of CGST Act, 2017
Category of Dispute: Limitation for Appeal / Condonation of Delay
Date of Judgement: 8 September 2022
Relevant Provisions: Section 107 of the CGST Act, 2017 – Appeal to Appellate Authority
Facts of the Case [¶1–¶6]
- The petitioner challenged the appellate order dated 2-3-2021 confirming the original order dated 28-2-2019.
- The original order was received by the petitioner on 13-3-2019, but the appeal was filed only on 14-11-2019—beyond the statutory limit.
- The delay was attributed to the non-receipt of the order by the officer in charge, due to her frequent travel for GST audits in 24 states.
- The petitioner claimed the omission was unintentional and due to the officer not being made aware of the order.
- The application for condonation of delay was rejected by the Appellate Authority on the ground that it lacked the power to condone delays beyond the prescribed period.
- The petitioner approached the High Court invoking its jurisdiction under Article 226.
Questions in Consideration [¶4, ¶7]
- Whether the High Court can invoke Article 226 to condone delay in filing appeal before Appellate Authority under CGST Act?
- Whether the delay in filing the appeal by the petitioner was due to bona fide and sufficient cause?
Observations of the Court [¶6–¶8]
- The Court observed the petitioner had substantiated the delay with valid and bona fide reasons including audit workload and internal communication lapses.
- It accepted that the GST regime posed heavy compliance burdens, especially for companies with registrations in multiple states.
- It relied on the Division Bench ruling in Simplex Infrastructures Ltd. v. Jt. Commissioner of Central Tax (W.A. No. 942/2021) to hold that Article 226 can be used to do complete justice.
- The court distinguished the respondent’s reliance on Laxmi Electronic Moulds & Precision Engg. (P.) Ltd. on factual grounds.
- The Court held the delay unintentional and exercised its discretionary jurisdiction to condone it.
Judgement of the Court [¶9]
- Writ Petition Allowed on condition of depositing ₹10,000 to the Advocates Welfare Fund, Bengaluru within 8 weeks.
- The impugned appellate order dated 2-3-2021 was quashed.
- Delay in filing the appeal was condoned.
- Matter remanded to the Appellate Authority to decide the appeal afresh on merits.
- The judgment was passed in light of the peculiar facts and shall not serve as a precedent.
Between Fine Lines
The Court permitted condonation of delay beyond statutory limits under its extraordinary constitutional powers due to valid justifications.
This judgment clarifies that procedural lapses, when adequately explained, should not deny substantive justice.
The GST regime’s transitional complexities were considered relevant.
High Courts can intervene when lower authorities are powerless due to statutory constraints.
However, such discretion is fact-specific and non-precedential.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Simplex Infrastructures Ltd. v. Jt. Commissioner of Central Tax | W.A. No. 942/2021, 03.12.2021 | Held that High Court can exercise powers under Article 226 to condone delay when justified. | Relied upon to condone delay |
| Laxmi Electronic Moulds & Precision Engg. (P.) Ltd. v. UOI | W.P. No. 53511/2018, 23.09.2021 | High Court refused to condone delay due to lack of sufficient cause. | Distinguished as factually inapplicable |
Takeaway
“When Statute Forbids, Equity Permits – Delay Condoned in View of Justice”




