Home Case Laws Appeal Dismissal Due to Non-Service of SCN Set Aside

Appeal Dismissal Due to Non-Service of SCN Set Aside

0
385

Case Title: M/s Om Traders v. Deputy Commissioner State Tax and Another
Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 2110 of 2024
Neutral Citation: 2024:AHC:190876
Date of Judgment: 05.12.2024
Category of Dispute: Validity of Ex-parte Assessment – Natural Justice – Appeal dismissed as time-barred
Relevant Sections: Section 73, CGST Act, 2017; Article 226, Constitution of India; CGST Rules on service of notice.


Facts of the Case (Para 2–4, 5)

  • The petitioner, a LLP engaged in exempted goods manufacturing, challenged the appellate order dated 25.09.2024 upholding assessment.

  • Assessment order dated 07.02.2024 imposed tax, interest, and penalty under Section 73. Petitioner contended the order was ex-parte since no SCN (DRC-01A) was served (Para 3).

  • The order was only later found on the GST portal under “view additional notices and orders.” It was never communicated physically or via e-mail (Para 3–4).

  • On learning of the order in September 2024, the petitioner filed appeal, but it was rejected as time-barred (Para 4).


Questions in Consideration (Para 4–5)

  1. Whether non-service of SCN and order through GST portal/email amounts to violation of natural justice?

  2. Whether dismissal of appeal as time-barred, when delay was due to lack of knowledge, renders the assessee remediless?


Observations of the Court (Para 5–9)

  • Issue of SCN not being reflected in “view notices and orders” tab and ex-parte liability has already been settled by Division Benches in Ola Fleet Technologies Pvt. Ltd. v. State of U.P. (22.07.2024), Shyam Roshan Transport (21.10.2024), Atul Agarwal (18.10.2024), and Akriti Food Industry LLP (03.12.2024) (Para 5–7).

  • Principle affirmed: No one should be condemned unheard; notice is mandatory before fastening liability (Para 8).

  • Following Akriti Food Industry LLP, identical orders were quashed (Para 9).


Judgment of the Court (Para 10–12)

  • The order dated 07.02.2024 is treated as a notice under Section 73 to enable petitioner to file reply with documents (Para 10).

  • Petitioner directed to file reply within 8 weeks; AO to grant hearing and pass fresh order within 4 weeks thereafter (Para 11).

  • Writ petition disposed of with above directions (Para 12).


Between Fine Lines (5-Line Simplified Summary)

The Court held that ex-parte assessments without proper SCN service are invalid. Even if the order was uploaded on GST portal, absence of notice on “view notices” denies fair opportunity. Appeal dismissed as time-barred cannot deprive taxpayer of remedy if delay is due to lack of knowledge. AO’s order is treated as notice; assessee may now reply. A fresh speaking order must follow hearing.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
Ola Fleet Technologies Pvt. Ltd. v. State of U.P. Writ Tax No. 855/2024 (22.07.2024) SCN not visible in GST portal’s “view notices”; ex-parte order invalid Directed AO to treat order as notice and pass fresh order
Shyam Roshan Transport v. State of U.P. Writ Tax No. 1756/2024 (21.10.2024) Similar grievance of non-service of notice Same relief granted
Atul Agarwal v. State of U.P. Writ Tax No. 1585/2024 (18.10.2024) Reiterated natural justice requirement in GST adjudication Order quashed; remand
M/s Akriti Food Industry LLP v. State of U.P. Writ Tax No. 2070/2024 (03.12.2024) Identical facts; SCN not served Order set aside; fresh opportunity directed

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY