The Bangalore Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, in Arakere Channappa Vishwanath v. Income Tax Officer, Ward-3(2)(1), Bengaluru, examined whether cumulative gross winnings reflected in an online gaming account could be assessed as taxable income when the corresponding buy-in amounts resulted in an overall loss. The decision was pronounced on 23 July 2026 in ITA No. 3016/Bang/2025 for Assessment Year 2022-23.
The assessee had participated in online gaming activities through platforms operated by Gameskraft Technologies Private Limited. Based on information received through the Insight Portal and a confirmation obtained from the gaming company under Section 133(6) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the Assessing Officer treated gross winnings of ₹2,33,52,271 as income from other sources.
The Assessing Officer invoked Sections 2(24)(ix), 56(2), 58(4) and 115BB of the Act and held that the entire amount reflected as gross winnings was taxable. According to the Assessing Officer, no expenditure, deduction or set-off of losses could be allowed against income arising from card games or other games. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) upheld the addition, observing that the assessee had not produced sufficient evidence to disprove the gross winnings reported by the gaming platform.
Before the Tribunal, the assessee contended that the amount of ₹2.33 crore represented cumulative wallet credits generated during several rounds of gameplay and not actual income. The same funds were repeatedly used for entering games, redeployed after winnings, withdrawn or circulated within the gaming wallet. Therefore, gross credits could not be equated with real income.
The information supplied by Gameskraft showed that the assessee’s aggregate buy-in or game participation amount was ₹2,61,51,624, while the cumulative gross winnings were ₹2,33,52,271. The gaming activity had consequently resulted in a net loss of ₹27,99,353. The assessee argued that the tax authorities had selectively relied upon the gross winnings figure while ignoring the corresponding buy-in amounts appearing in the same records.
Tribunal’s Findings
The Tribunal held that the Income-tax Act taxes real income and not the mere circulation or recycling of money within an online gaming wallet. Repeated credits and debits generated through several rounds of gameplay cannot automatically acquire the character of taxable income unless they result in an actual gain or accretion in the hands of the player.
The expression used in Section 115BB, as applicable to the relevant assessment year, was “income by way of winnings.” According to the Tribunal, this expression indicated that only the real winnings component was intended to be taxed and not the gross turnover or total movement of funds during gameplay.
The Tribunal also considered Sections 194BA and 115BBJ, introduced by the Finance Act, 2023, along with Rule 133 and CBDT Circular No. 05/2023. These provisions prescribe taxation and tax deduction at source on “net winnings” from online games after considering deposits, withdrawals, opening balances and closing balances in the user account.
Although these provisions were introduced subsequently, the Tribunal regarded the principles underlying them as clarificatory and declaratory. They explained the manner in which online gaming winnings should be determined where funds are repeatedly deposited, withdrawn, circulated or redeployed through electronic gaming wallets.
The Tribunal further relied upon the decisions in Royal Calcutta Turf Club and Delhi Race Club, where coordinate benches had held, in the context of horse-race winnings, that the amount invested by a participant must be considered while determining the actual income by way of winnings. The Tribunal found that the same underlying principle applied to online gaming transactions.
Section 58(4) Does Not Permit Taxation of Gross Wallet Credits
The Tribunal rejected the Revenue’s reliance on Section 58(4). It clarified that the provision prevents the deduction of expenditure or allowances while computing income from winnings. However, it does not authorise the tax authorities to treat every transactional entry or gross wallet credit as income.
Before Section 58(4) can apply, the tax authorities must first establish the existence of real income by way of winnings. Where the buy-in amounts exceed the gross winnings and the gaming activity results in a net loss, there is no taxable income upon which Section 58(4) can operate.
The Tribunal also observed that the absence of tax deduction at source by the online gaming intermediary supported the assessee’s contention that there were no actual net winnings chargeable to tax.
Decision
The ITAT held that only real net winnings arising from online gaming activities can be subjected to tax. Gross wallet credits or cumulative winnings recorded during intermediate stages of gameplay cannot be assessed independently without considering the associated buy-in amounts and the final outcome of the gaming account.
Since the material obtained from Gameskraft itself demonstrated that the assessee had suffered a net loss of ₹27,99,353, the Tribunal concluded that no taxable income arose from the online gaming activity. It therefore directed deletion of the addition of ₹2,33,52,271 and allowed the assessee’s appeal.
Why This Judgment Is Important
The ruling is significant for advocates, Chartered Accountants, tax consultants, online gaming intermediaries, corporate tax teams and taxpayers dealing with assessments of digital gaming transactions. It distinguishes genuine income from cumulative wallet movements and clarifies that gross gaming credits cannot be taxed without examining deposits, buy-ins, withdrawals and the ultimate net financial result.




