The Hyderabad Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal has partly allowed, for statistical purposes, the appeal filed by Clarion Agro Products Private Limited for Assessment Year 2019–20. The dispute arose from additions made following a search and seizure operation conducted under Section 132 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, at the premises of the assessee as part of the Jitender Roller Flour Mills Group search.
During the search, cash of ₹79,80,500 was found at the assessee’s business premises, whereas the cash balance recorded in its books was ₹12,37,402. The Assessing Officer consequently treated the difference of ₹67,43,098 as unexplained cash. A separate addition of ₹5,83,932 was also made on account of a net shortage in stock detected during physical verification. Both additions were confirmed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals).
Delay in Filing Appeal Condoned
The Tribunal first condoned a delay of 24 days in filing the appeal. Considering the explanation furnished through the condonation petition and affidavit, the limited period of delay and the absence of any serious objection from the Revenue, the Tribunal held that sufficient cause had been demonstrated and admitted the appeal for adjudication on merits.
Section 153D Approval Held Valid Despite Absence of DIN
The assessee challenged the approval granted under Section 153D on the grounds that it did not contain a Document Identification Number, included factual inaccuracies, failed to expressly refer to the assessment records examined and contained allegedly conditional observations.
The Tribunal rejected these objections by referring to Section 292BC, inserted by the Finance Act, 2026 with retrospective effect from 1 April 2021. It held that approvals relating to assessment proceedings are administrative and supervisory in nature and cannot be invalidated merely because of insufficiency of reasons or defects in their form, authentication or communication.
Accordingly, the absence of a DIN and the alleged clerical or factual errors in the approval letter were treated as technical defects that did not invalidate the approval under Section 153D.
The Tribunal also held that the approving authority’s observation that the applicability of Section 115BBE and initiation of penalty proceedings “may please be checked” was advisory rather than conditional. Since the approval was not made dependent upon the fulfilment of any condition, the assessment could not be quashed on this ground.
Wrong Mention of Section 69 Instead of Section 69A Not Fatal
The Assessing Officer had referred to Section 69 while making the addition for excess cash, whereas the Commissioner (Appeals) treated the amount as unexplained money covered by Section 69A.
The Tribunal held that the assessment order clearly identified the nature of the addition as unexplained cash found in the assessee’s possession during the search. Therefore, mentioning Section 69 instead of Section 69A was merely an error in quoting the applicable provision and did not affect the substance or validity of the addition.
It further observed that the Commissioner (Appeals) had only corrected the statutory provision applicable to the facts already recorded by the Assessing Officer. The nature, quantum and basis of the addition remained unchanged, and no new source of income was introduced. The correction, therefore, did not amount to enhancement of assessment or violation of the principles of natural justice.
Explanation for Excess Cash Rejected
The assessee contended that the excess cash belonged to its Managing Director, Shri Kanishk Gupta. According to the explanation, ₹70 lakh had been withdrawn from the partnership firm M/s Supreme Agro and advanced to Shri B. Venkata Rami Reddy for the proposed purchase of two villas. When the transaction did not materialise, the amount was allegedly refunded and was subsequently found at the assessee’s premises.
The Tribunal found significant inconsistencies in this explanation. The advances were stated to have been paid in August and October 2017, whereas the withdrawal of ₹70 lakh from M/s Supreme Agro was recorded only on 31 March 2018. The contemporaneous books, therefore, did not establish that the Managing Director possessed the cash on the dates when the advances were allegedly made.
The assessee also failed to produce any receipt, confirmation, bank record or other documentary evidence showing that the alleged villa advance had subsequently been refunded.
The Tribunal further noted that ₹17,43,098 of the excess cash was found with the cashier of the assessee-company. This fact was inconsistent with the claim that the money represented the personal funds of the Managing Director.
Importantly, in the statement recorded immediately after the search, the Managing Director had accepted the cash found in his chamber and with the cashier as old undisclosed business income. The Tribunal held that this contemporaneous statement carried substantial evidentiary value and that the later explanation appeared to be an unsupported afterthought.
Considering the absence of credible evidence, inconsistencies in the cash-flow explanation and the location from which the money was recovered, the Tribunal upheld the addition of ₹67,43,098 as unexplained cash.
Stock-Shortage Addition Remanded for Fresh Examination
The second addition concerned a net stock shortage of 31.77 metric tonnes, valued at ₹5,83,932. The assessee argued that it manufactured Rawa, Atta and Maida from wheat and that stock could remain at different stages of production. It also claimed that the alleged shortage represented only about 0.044 per cent of total production and could be attributable to normal process loss, wastage or work-in-progress.
The Tribunal accepted that manufacturing concerns may ordinarily experience process loss and may hold stock at different stages of production. It held that these factors should be considered while examining variations between physical stock and book stock.
However, the assessee had not produced quantitative reconciliation, manufacturing records, documentary evidence or a scientific working to substantiate the claimed process loss or work-in-progress. The Tribunal therefore restored the issue to the Assessing Officer for fresh adjudication after giving the assessee an adequate opportunity to submit supporting material.
Decision
The ITAT Hyderabad upheld the addition of ₹67,43,098 relating to unexplained cash and rejected the legal challenges concerning the Section 153D approval and the correction from Section 69 to Section 69A.
The addition of ₹5,83,932 relating to the alleged stock shortage was set aside and remanded to the Assessing Officer for reconsideration. Consequently, the assessee’s appeal was partly allowed for statistical purposes.
The ruling highlights that a technical defect in an administrative approval may not invalidate an assessment where Section 292BC applies. It also reinforces that explanations regarding cash discovered during a search must be supported by contemporaneous records, credible evidence and a consistent cash trail.




