Case Title: Shahil Traders v. State of U.P.
Court: High Court of Allahabad
Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 178 of 2023
Date of Judgement: 25 May 2023
Relevant Section: Section 129(1)(a) and 129(1)(b) of the UPGST Act, 2017
Category of Dispute: Penalty – Detention and Seizure under GST
Facts of the Case [¶2–5]
- The petitioner, a registered dealer in iron scrap, dispatched goods to M/s Harshika Steel Sales in Ludhiana, Punjab, under a valid tax invoice and E-Way Bill dated 02.01.2023.
- The vehicle bearing registration No. PB11-CQ-2981 carrying the consignment was intercepted and detained on 04.01.2023 by the authorities in Uttar Pradesh.
- The driver presented both the tax invoice and the E-Way Bill at the time of interception. However, authorities doubted the genuineness of the consignee despite document production.
- The petition challenged detention order (GST MOV-06), penalty order (MOV-09), and recovery notice (DRC-07) imposing penalty of ₹6,17,087 under Section 129(1)(b).
Questions in Consideration [¶3, ¶6–7]
- Whether penalty under Section 129(1)(b) of the UPGST Act was justified when valid documents were produced during interception?
- Whether the owner of goods, having presented the required documents, should be liable only under Section 129(1)(a)?
Observations of the Court [¶6–11]
- The Court noted that the tax invoice and E-Way Bill were indeed presented during detention, and there was no conclusive finding on their falsity or invalidity [¶8].
- The Court referenced CBIC Circular dated 31.12.2018 and emphasized that in such scenarios, security under Section 129(1)(a) could be demanded, but penalty under Section 129(1)(b) was not sustainable [¶6].
- The Court found support in two earlier decisions:
- Margo Brush India v. State of U.P., Writ Tax No. 1580 of 2022 [¶9]
- Riya Traders v. State of U.P., Writ Tax No. 28 of 2023 [¶10]
- In both cited cases, it was held that where ownership and documentation were not in dispute, recourse to Section 129(1)(b) was unwarranted.
Judgement of the Court [¶12]
- The writ petition was allowed.
- The impugned penalty order (MOV-09 dated 16.01.2023) was set aside.
- The matter was remitted to the proper officer to issue a fresh order within two weeks, treating the petitioner as eligible under Section 129(1)(a) (owner coming forward for release).
Between Fine Lines
This case reinforces that mere suspicion about the consignee’s genuineness, in the presence of valid tax documents, cannot attract harsher penalties under Section 129(1)(b). When the consignor accepts ownership and documentation is in order, security under Section 129(1)(a) is appropriate. Courts continue to shield genuine trade from overzealous penalty imposition. The ruling upholds procedural fairness and limits misuse of discretionary powers.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Margo Brush India v. State of U.P. | Writ Tax No. 1580 of 2022 | Consignor and consignee were registered and present. Valid documents were produced. | Penalty under 129(1)(b) quashed; remand ordered |
| Riya Traders v. State of U.P. | Writ Tax No. 28 of 2023 | Consignor was a registered dealer; documents were valid; penalty was wrongly imposed on driver | Penalty set aside; fresh opportunity to be given to owner |
Takeaway for the Case:
“Documentation Defended, Penalty Prevented”




