Zhudao Infotech Pvt Ltd v. Principal Additional Director General
Delhi High Court | W.P.(C) No. 3428 of 2023 | CM APPL. No. 13239 & 25805 of 2023
Category: Provisional Attachment | Section 83 of CGST Act | Rule 159(5) of CGST Rules
Date of Judgment: 22-May-2023
Facts of the Case [¶1–18]
- Zhudao Infotech Pvt Ltd (ZIPL) operates a payment aggregator platform ‘Onion-Pay’, facilitating payments between merchants and customers. [¶4–5]
- On 6 and 7 October 2022, a search was conducted on ZIPL’s premises, following which three of its bank accounts were provisionally attached under Section 83 of CGST Act by orders dated 6-10-2022 and 10-10-2022. [¶1, ¶9]
- ZIPL’s objections under Rule 159(5) were initially rejected on the ground of incorrect format; a writ was filed [W.P.(C) No. 492/2023], leading the Court to direct a reasoned order. [¶10–11]
- In compliance, respondent passed a speaking order on 1-2-2023 rejecting ZIPL’s objections, justifying attachment based on suspicion that merchants on ZIPL’s platform were fake and involved in illegal gambling. [¶13–17]
- It was accepted that there was no specific GST liability against ZIPL itself. Respondents alleged that certain merchants transacting through ZIPL were involved in fraud, but there was no concrete material against ZIPL. [¶20–23]
Question(s) in Consideration [¶19, ¶24]
- Whether ZIPL’s bank accounts could be provisionally attached under Section 83 of CGST Act in the absence of any tax liability on ZIPL itself?
- Whether such attachment to secure dues of third-party merchants is permissible?
Observations of the Court [¶19–27]
- Section 83 permits provisional attachment only of assets of the taxable person or person covered under Section 122(1A), and only if the Commissioner forms an opinion that it is necessary to protect government revenue. [¶24]
- No tax demand existed against ZIPL; the attachment was solely to safeguard possible dues from third-party merchants. [¶23–24]
- Attachment of ZIPL’s account to secure government dues from merchants using its platform is impermissible in law. [¶24]
- Directions requiring ZIPL to obtain NOCs from recipient banks lacked any legal basis. [¶25]
- Both parties agreed that ZIPL would directly remit dues to genuine merchants’ specified bank accounts, and the remaining funds be allowed to be transferred to ZIPL’s account. [¶26–27]
Judgment of the Court [¶28–31]
- The impugned orders attaching ZIPL’s bank accounts were quashed.
- ZIPL was permitted to remit funds to specified merchants’ bank accounts and retain the remaining Rs. 69.92 crores.
- The department is free to proceed against any non-genuine merchants or ZIPL, in accordance with law, in future if necessary. [¶29–30]
- Writ petition disposed accordingly. [¶31]
Between Fine Lines
- The court ruled that ZIPL’s bank accounts cannot be attached under Section 83 when no GST dues are pending against it.
- Attachment under Section 83 must be of assets of the taxable person who is liable.
- ZIPL’s role as a payment intermediary does not warrant punitive measures meant for defaulting suppliers.
- Court upheld merchant-wise remittance, ensuring legitimate dues are paid while protecting ZIPL’s business.
- The decision reinforces the principle that protective measures must be proportional and legally justified.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Case Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| No specific prior cases cited in detail within the order | – | The order primarily dealt with interpretation of Section 83 and ZIPL’s specific facts. | – |
Takeaway
“Attachment Without Liability – The Limits of Section 83 Unveiled”




