Case Title: Kaleidoscope v. State of West Bengal
Court: High Court of Calcutta
Petition No.: MAT No. 90 of 2024, IA No. CAN 1 of 2024
Relevant Sections: Section 74(1) of WBGST Act, 2019, Rule 142(1) of WBGST Rules, 2017
Category of Dispute: Provisional Attachment under GST
Date of Judgement: 6 February 2024
Relevant Provisions: Section 83 of CGST Act (provisional attachment); Rule 142(1) of CGST Rules
Facts of the Case [Para 2–3]
The appellant, Kaleidoscope, challenged the order dated 09.01.2024 which dismissed their writ petition (WPA 29214 of 2023) on the ground of disputed facts.
A show cause notice under Section 74(1) of the WBGST Act was issued on 06.12.2023 alleging tax liability of ₹92,44,628. The appellant filed its reply in time. However, beginning 20.12.2023, 13 provisional attachment orders in Form GST DRC-22 were issued, freezing all their bank accounts, effectively paralysing their business operations.
Questions in Consideration [Para 3–4]
- Whether the provisional attachment of all bank accounts of the appellant, pending adjudication of the show cause notice, was legally sustainable?
- Whether the attachment was disproportionate and violated principles of natural justice?
Observations of the Court [Para 4–5]
The Court held that since the show cause notice was still pending adjudication and no material was placed by the department to show that the appellant was attempting to evade tax, the provisional attachment orders appeared harsh and disproportionate.
The Court emphasized that provisional attachment powers under GST laws are extraordinary in nature and must be used judiciously. Blanket attachment of all bank accounts without urgency or supporting material was unjustified.
Judgement of the Court [Para 5–6]
The Division Bench allowed the appeal. It:
- Set aside the order dismissing the writ petition.
- Quashed all 13 provisional attachment orders issued in Form GST DRC-22.
- Permitted the appellant to operate its bank accounts and resume business.
- Directed the GST authorities to adjudicate the show cause notice within 3 weeks from receipt of the server copy of the order.
- Clarified that no observation was made on the merits and that the adjudicating authority shall proceed independently.
Between Fine Lines
This judgment underlines that provisional attachment under GST should be a last resort and must not cripple business without concrete grounds. Mere issuance of show cause notice is not enough—there must be real apprehension of tax evasion. The case reiterates judicial restraint in pre-adjudication attachment, preserving business continuity.
Summary of Referred Cases
No specific prior case laws were cited in the judgment.
| Case Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| None cited | – | – | – |
Takeaway:
“Provisional Attachment Must Not Paralysise – Discretion Must be Judicious”




