Home Updates Calcutta High Court Quashes GST Order: Section 74 Cannot Be Invoked Mechanically...

Calcutta High Court Quashes GST Order: Section 74 Cannot Be Invoked Mechanically to Overcome Limitation

0
395

The Calcutta High Court in M/s. Cart Infralog Ltd. & Anr. v. The Additional Commissioner, HQ Anti-Evasion Unit, CGST & CX, Kolkata South Commissionerate & Ors., WPA 16556 of 2025 with IA No. CAN 1 of 2025, decided on 27 August 2026, examined important issues concerning denial of Input Tax Credit due to supplier default, invocation of Section 74 of the CGST Act to claim extended limitation, and the requirement of a reasoned adjudication consistent with principles of natural justice.

The dispute arose from a Show Cause Notice dated 11 June 2025 issued under Section 74 of the CGST Act for Financial Years 2018-19, 2019-20 and 2023-24. The allegations included availment and utilisation of allegedly ineligible ITC of ₹88,57,040 and excess ITC of ₹1,48,84,011 based on comparison of GSTR-3B with GSTR-2A. The principal demand was stated to be ₹2,37,41,051, while the aggregate demand including interest and penalty was approximately ₹6.3 crore.

The petitioners contended that the purchases were supported by tax invoices, e-way bills, transport receipts, proof of receipt of goods and payments through banking channels. They further pointed out that proceedings had already been initiated by the Department against a defaulting supplier, M/s. Aster Trading Company, for non-filing of GSTR-3B.

ITC Cannot Be Automatically Denied Merely Because of Supplier Default

The Court identified the core question as whether ITC could be denied to a bona fide purchaser merely because the supplier had failed to deposit tax, file GSTR-3B or because the relevant invoices were not reflected in GSTR-2A.

The Court observed that there was no allegation that the petitioners were not in possession of valid tax invoices or that the goods or services had not been received. Accordingly, the requirements under Sections 16(2)(a) and 16(2)(b) were not disputed.

Relying upon the Division Bench judgment in Suncraft Energy Pvt. Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner, State Tax, which had subsequently attained finality following dismissal of the Special Leave Petition by the Supreme Court, the Court held that mere non-reflection of invoices in GSTR-2A could not, by itself, result in automatic denial of ITC to a bona fide purchaser.

The Court also noted that where the Department had itself initiated proceedings against the defaulting supplier, it could not seek double recovery by recovering the same tax from both the supplier and the recipient. The Department was required first to proceed against the defaulting supplier in accordance with law.

Significantly, there was also no allegation of collusion between the petitioners and the concerned supplier.

Mechanical Invocation of Section 74 to Overcome Limitation Rejected

The Court separately examined whether Section 74 could be invoked by merely using expressions such as “fraud”, “wilful misstatement” or “suppression of facts” without supporting particulars.

For Financial Year 2018-19, the Court found that proceedings were ex facie beyond the normal limitation contemplated under Section 73(10). It observed that the Department had invoked Section 74 in an attempt to avail the extended period.

The Court held that a bare or mechanical allegation of fraud, suppression or wilful misstatement was insufficient. The Show Cause Notice was required to disclose the factual basis and material demonstrating how the statutory ingredients of Section 74 were satisfied.

Where the notice merely employed statutory terminology without explaining the alleged fraudulent conduct or suppression, extended limitation could not be invoked simply to overcome the expiry of the normal limitation period.

The Court therefore held that invocation of Section 74, to that extent, was without jurisdiction and amounted to a colourable exercise of power.

Writ Petition Maintainable Despite Alternative Remedy

The Revenue argued that the petitioners should pursue the statutory appellate remedy under Section 107 of the CGST Act because an Order-in-Original had already been passed during the pendency of the writ proceedings.

The Court, however, found that the case involved allegations of non-application of mind, failure to properly consider the petitioners’ documents and violation of principles of natural justice.

Accordingly, the availability of an alternative appellate remedy did not bar exercise of writ jurisdiction in the circumstances of the case.

Order-in-Original and Recovery Notice Quashed

The Calcutta High Court quashed and set aside the Order-in-Original dated 9 December 2025 as well as the consequential recovery notice dated 12 June 2026.

The adjudicating authority was directed to reconsider the petitioners’ reply dated 10 November 2025 and all supporting documents in light of the binding precedents relied upon by the petitioners, including Suncraft Energy Pvt. Ltd. and G.R. Infra Projects Pvt. Ltd.

The authority was further directed to provide an opportunity of personal hearing and pass a reasoned and speaking order in accordance with law within four weeks from communication of the High Court’s order.

The Court clarified that the adjudicating authority would remain free to take an independent decision and should not be influenced by the Court’s observations except insofar as binding judicial precedents were required to be considered.

₹10 Lakh Deposit Made a Condition of Remand

As a condition for remand and as prima facie proof of bona fides, the petitioners were directed to deposit ₹10 lakh through Form GST DRC-03 under protest within four weeks.

The amount would remain subject to the outcome of the fresh adjudication and would either be adjusted against any final liability or refunded if the petitioners ultimately succeeded.

The Court further directed that if the deposit was not made within the stipulated period, the benefit of the order would automatically stand vacated and the Department would be entitled to proceed with recovery in accordance with law.

Significance of the Judgment

The judgment reinforces two significant principles under GST law. First, ITC should not be mechanically denied to a bona fide recipient solely because of a supplier’s failure to discharge its statutory obligations, particularly where genuine movement of goods, tax invoices and payments are supported by evidence and no collusion is alleged.

Second, the extended limitation available under Section 74 cannot be invoked merely by reproducing statutory expressions such as fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression. The Show Cause Notice must contain sufficient factual particulars demonstrating why the case falls within Section 74.

The ruling is therefore relevant for taxpayers and GST practitioners dealing with supplier-default ITC disputes, GSTR-2A/3B mismatches, extended limitation, jurisdictional challenges and adjudication orders passed without adequate consideration of documentary evidence.

 

Download

LEAVE A REPLY