Case Summary: M/s Goyal Metal Udyog v. Commissioner of CGST & Anr., Delhi High Court, W.P.(C) 7618/2019 (22.08.2023)
Court: Delhi High Court
Case Title: M/s. Goyal Metal Udyog v. Commissioner of Central Goods & Services Tax & Anr.
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 7618/2019 & CM Appl. 42253/2019
Category: Search & Seizure – Scope of Section 67(2) – Validity of Seizure of Cash
Date of Judgement: 22 August 2023
Relevant Provisions:
-
Section 67(2), CGST Act, 2017 – Power of inspection, search and seizure
-
Section 70, CGST Act, 2017 – Power to summon
-
Request for Refund/Adjustment: No specific section invoked; general refund framework under Section 54
FACTS (with para references)
The petitioner, a sole proprietor operating as Goyal Metal Udyog, challenged proceedings initiated following a search conducted by the Anti-Evasion Branch of CGST Delhi East on 03.05.2018 at his business premises (para 2).
During the search, although all raw materials and finished goods were found duly recorded in the books, the officers located ₹50,70,000 in Indian currency kept in a locker (para 3). The petitioner explained that the cash belonged to his family members and was temporarily shifted from their residence undergoing renovation (para 4).
Following the seizure, the officers issued summons under Section 70 seeking extensive documents and bank statements for preceding five years (para 5). The seized cash was deposited with Syndicate Bank in the name of the Commissioner, CGST (para 6). Despite repeated requests, the cash and documents were not released (paras 7–10).
The petitioner was subsequently asked to deposit ₹11,41,750 towards alleged tax, interest and penalty on the premise that the seized cash reflected undisclosed sales. Although disputing any liability, the petitioner deposited the amount on 23.11.2018 based on the assurance that the cash would then be released (para 8). However, the assurance was not honoured (para 9).
Contending that seizure of cash is not authorised under Section 67(2), the petitioner sought quashing of proceedings, release of the seized amount and adjustment/refund of the voluntary deposit (para 11–12).
QUESTIONS OF LAW / ISSUES (flowing form)
-
Whether Section 67(2) of the CGST Act empowers GST officers to seize Indian currency on the mere suspicion that it represents unaccounted or undisclosed business turnover?
-
Whether the petitioner is entitled to the release of ₹50,70,000 seized during search?
-
Whether the amount of ₹11,41,750 deposited voluntarily under alleged coercion can be adjusted against future tax liability or must be processed under the refund mechanism?
-
Whether limitation for any future proceedings by either side should exclude the period during which the writ petition remained pending?
COURT’S OBSERVATIONS (with para references)
The Court noted that the central issue regarding the power to seize cash under Section 67(2) stands settled by the Court’s prior judgment in Deepak Khandelwal Proprietor M/s Shri Shyam Metal v. Commissioner of CGST, Delhi West (2023:DHC:5823-DB), which held that currency is not “goods” liable to seizure under Section 67(2) (para 13).
Relying on this, the Court held that the seizure of currency in the present case is illegal and unsustainable (para 14).
On the issue of the voluntary deposit of ₹11,41,750, the Court recorded that the amount was deposited voluntarily and that the department has not accepted it as refundable (para 15). The Court clarified that while the department may proceed in accordance with law regarding the deposited amount, the petitioner is equally free to file an appropriate refund application, if due.
Further, the Court determined that the pendency of the writ petition should not prejudice statutory limitation for any fresh proceedings and expressly excluded the entire period from the filing of the petition till the date of the judgment (para 16).
JUDGMENT / VERDICT (with para references)
The writ petition was allowed (para 17). The Court held:
-
Seizure of currency is ultra vires Section 67(2); officers have no authority to seize cash merely because it may be unaccounted.
-
The respondents were directed to release the proceeds of the fixed deposit (seized amount + interest) to the petitioner’s bank account within one week (para 18).
-
The petitioner may seek refund of ₹11,41,750 through proper application; the department may also initiate any permissible action regarding the deposit since the matter remained pending (para 15).
-
Limitation period for future proceedings by either party stands excluded for the entire pendency of the writ petition (para 16).
SUMMARY OF CASES REFERRED (TABLE)
| Case Referred | Court | Principle Laid Down | Relevance to Present Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deepak Khandelwal Proprietor M/s Shri Shyam Metal v. Commissioner of CGST, Delhi West (2023:DHC:5823-DB) | Delhi High Court | Held that cash is not “goods” under Section 67(2); GST officers have no power to seize currency during search. | Applied directly; formed the legal basis for declaring the seizure of ₹50,70,000 illegal. |
BETWEEN FINE LINES (Practical Takeaway)
GST authorities cannot seize cash during search operations under Section 67(2), even if they suspect it to be unaccounted turnover. Any such seizure is void. Taxpayers whose currency is seized may seek immediate release. Voluntary deposits made during search-related pressures must be processed under the refund mechanism, and both taxpayers and the department retain the right to initiate proceedings once limitation is adjusted for litigation pendency.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




