Home Case Laws Seizure of silver bars under Section 67 CGST Act held invalid as...

Seizure of silver bars under Section 67 CGST Act held invalid as such assets were not “goods liable for confiscation” arising from taxable supplies

0
275

Case Summary: Seizure of silver bars quashed as Section 67 CGST Act limits seizure to goods liable for confiscation and excludes valuable assets not linked to taxable supplies

Case Title: M/s Narendra Polypack Industries v. Additional Director General, Directorate General of GST Intelligence & Ors.
Court: Delhi High Court
Petition: W.P.(C) 8300/2023
Date of Judgment: 17.10.2023
Statutory Provisions: Section 67(2), Section 2(52) of the CGST Act, 2017
Category of Dispute: Search & Seizure – Scope of Section 67 – Non-taxable assets
Source: Judgment document provided by user


FACTS OF THE CASE

(Paras 1–2, 11–12)
The petitioner was subjected to a search on 07.02.2023 by DGGI under Section 67(2) of the CGST Act, during which silver bars and coins were seized. The search authorization was premised on “reason to believe” that the petitioner was engaged in clandestine manufacture and supply of laminations, its taxable commodity. The department later contended (through an additional affidavit) that the seized silver was purchased using cash generated from alleged clandestine clearance of packaging material. They further alleged that the proprietor was engaged in trading silver to evade GST.

The petitioner challenged the seizure, arguing that silver has no nexus with the alleged taxable supplies (laminations) and is not “goods liable for confiscation” under Section 67(2). The issue was stated to be covered by the earlier judgment in Deepak Khandelwal v. Commissioner of CGST (2023:DHC:5823-DB).


QUESTIONS / ISSUES BEFORE THE COURT

(Emerging from Paras 1, 3–12)

  1. Whether silver bars and coins can be seized under Section 67(2) of the CGST Act when they are not the taxable goods involved in the alleged evasion.

  2. Whether “things” under Section 67 includes valuable movable assets or is restricted to items containing information relevant to proceedings.

  3. Whether mere inability to explain lawful purchase of silver empowers officers to seize such assets during a GST search.


OBSERVATIONS OF THE COURT

(Paras 3–12)

  1. The Court reaffirmed its earlier interpretation in Deepak Khandelwal that Section 67(2) restricts seizure to:

    • Goods liable for confiscation, and

    • Documents/books/things useful or relevant for proceedings.

  2. Definition of goods in Section 2(52) covers movable property other than money and securities (Para 6). However, the term “goods” in Section 67 relates only to goods forming the subject matter of taxable supply (Para 6).

  3. The Court clarified that the term “things” must take colour from “documents and books” (Paras 7–8). Accordingly, “things” extend only to informational and documentary material, not valuable assets like silver.

  4. Officers may find several movable assets during search, but only those liable for confiscation under the GST law can be seized (Para 9).

  5. The scope of Section 67 presupposes reason to believe of suppression of transactions of goods/services which form the taxable supply chain (Para 10).

  6. In this case, the search was authorised based on allegations concerning laminations, not silver. Therefore, silver is not “goods liable for confiscation” under Section 67 (Para 11).

  7. The petitioner’s failure to produce purchase documents for silver is irrelevant for Section 67 proceedings relating to laminations (Para 12).

  8. The department is free to investigate alleged silver trading separately under GST, if they later develop valid “reason to believe” (Para 13).


JUDGMENT / VERDICT

(Paras 14 & 13)

The Delhi High Court directed immediate release of the seized silver bars and coins, holding that:

  • The seizure of silver under Section 67(2) was illegal, as silver had no nexus with the taxable goods (laminations) which formed the basis of the search.

  • Valuable assets cannot be seized merely because they are unaccounted, as they do not fall within “documents, books or things” or “goods liable for confiscation” (Paras 8–9).

  • The department is at liberty to proceed with further investigation regarding alleged silver trading under appropriate statutory provisions (Para 13).

Thus, the seizure was quashed for lack of statutory authority.


SUMMARY OF CASES REFERRED

Case Name Court Ratio / Verdict Relevance
Deepak Khandelwal Proprietor M/s Shri Shyam Metal v. Commissioner of CGST, Delhi West Delhi High Court Held that “things” under Section 67 must take colour from “documents and books”; seizure can extend only to items containing relevant information; valuable assets cannot be seized absent nexus with taxable supplies. Applied directly to hold that silver bars could not be seized.

BETWEEN FINE LINES – PRACTICAL TAKEAWAYS FOR INDUSTRY

This ruling underscores that officers cannot seize high-value personal or business assets (like gold, silver, cash equivalents) during a GST search unless such assets form part of the taxable supply chain or are liable for confiscation under the Act. Section 67 is not a tool for seizing unaccounted wealth or investment assets. Businesses should maintain clarity on the nature of their taxable supplies and ensure that any assets found on premises are demonstrably unrelated to such supplies, thereby keeping them outside the purview of GST seizure powers.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY