Case Title: Mobile Shoppe v. Union of India
Court: High Court of Gujarat
Petition Number: R/Special Civil Application No. 10110 of 2020
Date of Judgment: 20 January 2023
Relevant Sections: Section 16 of IGST Act, Rule 96 and 138A of CGST Rules, Section 67 & 70 of CGST Act, Section 99B of Customs Act
Category of Dispute: Refund – IGST on Export
Takeaway:
Jurisdictional Boundaries in IGST Refunds – Customs or GST?
Facts of the Case
[¶1.1–1.4] Petitioner exported mobile phones procured through sister concern M/s. Anjali Enterprise, delivered directly to airports for export. IGST was paid and refunds were processed by Customs under Rule 96, CGST Rules.
[¶1.5–1.6] A single e-way bill was generated by the vendor showing the airport as the delivery address. GST officers insisted on a second e-way bill, terming its absence a document deficiency.
[¶1.7–1.10] GST officials detained export cargo and issued summons despite the petitioner’s explanation and customs clearance. Goods were later released by Customs on 7-8-2020.
[¶1.11–1.14] Further summons were issued, demanding documents already seized. Petitioner argued CGST officials lacked jurisdiction to scrutinize IGST refunds processed by Customs.
[¶4.1–4.9] Respondents alleged the petitioner used mismatched addresses and invalid e-way bills, and availed ITC fraudulently. They relied on Notification No. 02/2020-Central Tax and Rule 138A to justify investigation.
Question(s) in Consideration
[¶2, ¶6, ¶10]
- Whether CGST officers have jurisdiction to scrutinize refund of IGST paid on exports when processed by Customs under Rule 96 of CGST Rules?
- Whether non-generation of a second e-way bill in a “bill-to-ship-to” model invalidates IGST refund?
- Whether coercive actions like detention and summons were lawful without a show cause notice or adjudication?
Observations of the Court
[¶3, ¶6, ¶10, ¶11]
- Respondent No. 2 (CGST Officer) had no clear jurisdiction to interfere with IGST refund processed by Customs.
- The Court took serious note that CGST officials directed Customs to withhold refund without proper authority.
- CBIC Press Release dated 23-4-2018 clarified that only one e-way bill is needed for bill-to-ship-to transactions.
- No show cause notice was issued, and investigation had not been concluded.
- Customs had examined and released the cargo after being satisfied with documentation.
Between Fine Lines
- CGST officers cannot override Customs jurisdiction for IGST export refunds.
- Single e-way bill is sufficient in bill-to-ship-to exports if backed by proper documentation.
- Customs’ satisfaction in export clearance prevails unless proven fraudulent.
- Threats of coercive action without adjudication are judicially unsustainable.
- The refund mechanism under Rule 96 is autonomous and must be respected.
Summary of Referred Cases
| S.No | Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| 1 | Vodafone Idea Ltd. v. Dy. CIT | [2019] 111 taxmann.com 451 (Bom.) | Scrutiny assessments must not delay genuine refunds without recorded reasons & prior approvals. | Powers must be exercised cautiously with due safeguards. |
| 2 | Ganesh Sales Corporation v. State of Gujarat | [2016] 68 taxmann.com 243 (Guj.) | Refunds cannot be withheld unless conditions of Section 39 are strictly met. | Authority lacked jurisdiction to withhold refund. |




