Case Title: D. Murali Mohan Patanaik v. Secretary to Government of Odisha, Finance Department
Court: High Court of Orissa
Petition No.: W.P.(C) No. 34787 of 2022
Date of Judgment: January 31, 2023
Category: Refund – Claim Denied for Non-Protest
Relevant Sections: Section 73(5) of OGST Act and Rule 142(1A), (2A) of OGST Rules
Facts of the Case
[Para 1-3]
The petitioner, a registered dealer and distributor of Grasim Cement in Koraput district, was issued a notice dated 19.02.2022 under Section 73(5) of the OGST Act requiring production of documents relating to stock and vehicles used for e-way bills. Tax liability for the periods Oct 2018–Mar 2019, Apr 2019–Feb 2020, and Apr 2020–Mar 2021 was determined.
[Para 3]
Four cement-laden vehicles were detained; petitioner claims to have paid tax “under protest” for their release but failed to produce contemporaneous documentation showing such protest.
[Para 5]
Petitioner made full tax payment without availing partial payment or submission facility under Rule 142(1A) of OGST Rules. A letter later dated 06.07.2022 objected to liability but did not assert that payment was under protest.
[Para 6]
The Department, via Form GST DRC-05 dated 01.08.2022, concluded proceedings citing full payment of tax, interest, and penalty by the petitioner.
Questions in Consideration
[Para 1-2, 7]
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to a refund of tax paid on the ground that it was made under protest.
- Whether the petitioner can seek a right to appeal despite issuance of DRC-05 concluding proceedings.
Judgment of the Court
[Para 10]
- The Court found no basis to grant refund or appellate relief.
- The writ petition was dismissed.
Between Fine Lines
- Making a tax payment without registering a protest nullifies the right to contest it later.
- Rule 142(1A) of OGST Rules provides for objections before payment, which must be followed strictly.
- Filing an appeal post DRC-05 is not permitted when full payment is made without protest.
- A letter sent months later cannot substitute a formal protest.
- The case underscores the procedural diligence required in GST disputes.
Summary of Referred Cases
| S.No | Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| 1 | None explicitly cited in judgment | — | — | — |
Takeaway:
“No Protest, No Appeal – Procedural Lapse Defeats Refund Claim”




