Home Case Laws Refund is not allowed for deposit made under demand in case where...

Refund is not allowed for deposit made under demand in case where no documents were produced to prove such deposit were made under protest or no submission has been made against such demand in Part-B of GSTR-DRC-01A.

0
267

Case Title: D. Murali Mohan Patanaik v. Secretary to Government of Odisha, Finance Department

Court: High Court of Orissa

Petition No.: W.P.(C) No. 34787 of 2022

Date of Judgment: January 31, 2023

Category: Refund – Claim Denied for Non-Protest

Relevant Sections: Section 73(5) of OGST Act and Rule 142(1A), (2A) of OGST Rules

 

Facts of the Case

[Para 1-3]
The petitioner, a registered dealer and distributor of Grasim Cement in Koraput district, was issued a notice dated 19.02.2022 under Section 73(5) of the OGST Act requiring production of documents relating to stock and vehicles used for e-way bills. Tax liability for the periods Oct 2018–Mar 2019, Apr 2019–Feb 2020, and Apr 2020–Mar 2021 was determined.

[Para 3]
Four cement-laden vehicles were detained; petitioner claims to have paid tax “under protest” for their release but failed to produce contemporaneous documentation showing such protest.

[Para 5]
Petitioner made full tax payment without availing partial payment or submission facility under Rule 142(1A) of OGST Rules. A letter later dated 06.07.2022 objected to liability but did not assert that payment was under protest.

[Para 6]
The Department, via Form GST DRC-05 dated 01.08.2022, concluded proceedings citing full payment of tax, interest, and penalty by the petitioner.

 

Questions in Consideration

[Para 1-2, 7]

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to a refund of tax paid on the ground that it was made under protest.
  2. Whether the petitioner can seek a right to appeal despite issuance of DRC-05 concluding proceedings.

Judgment of the Court

[Para 10]

  • The Court found no basis to grant refund or appellate relief.
  • The writ petition was dismissed.

 

Between Fine Lines

  1. Making a tax payment without registering a protest nullifies the right to contest it later.
  2. Rule 142(1A) of OGST Rules provides for objections before payment, which must be followed strictly.
  3. Filing an appeal post DRC-05 is not permitted when full payment is made without protest.
  4. A letter sent months later cannot substitute a formal protest.
  5. The case underscores the procedural diligence required in GST disputes.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

S.No Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
1 None explicitly cited in judgment — — —

 

Takeaway:

“No Protest, No Appeal – Procedural Lapse Defeats Refund Claim”

LEAVE A REPLY