Case Title: Joint Commissioner (Intelligence & Enforcement) & Anr. v. M/s Lakshmi Mobile Accessories
Court: High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam
Case No.: W.A. No. 258 of 2025 (against W.P.(C) No. 2911 of 2025)
Date of Judgment: 05.02.2025
Category: GST – Demand under Section 74 – Validity of Consolidated Show Cause Notice
Relevant Provisions: Section 74(1), (2), (9), (10) of the CGST/SGST Act, 2017
Facts of the Case (Paras 2–3)
-
M/s Lakshmi Mobile Accessories received a consolidated show cause notice (SCN) under Section 74 for alleged suppression of turnover for six financial years (2017-18 to 2023-24).
-
The assessee challenged it on grounds that a single consolidated SCN curtailed limitation and reply rights, particularly because the earliest year (2017-18) was expiring on 07.02.2025 under Section 74(10).
-
It was also contended that denial of opportunity for cross-examination of witnesses relied upon in SCN prejudiced them.
Questions in Consideration (Paras 3–4)
-
Whether a consolidated show cause notice covering multiple financial years under Section 74 CGST Act is valid?
-
Whether denial of cross-examination of witnesses could be a ground to quash the SCN at notice stage?
-
Whether separate adjudication orders could be permitted for each year despite one consolidated SCN being issued?
Observations of the Court (Paras 6–10)
-
Section 74 does not mandate issuance of consolidated SCNs; each financial year has an independent limitation period (Para 6–7).
-
Issuing a composite SCN prejudices assessee since limitation for earliest year cuts short the opportunity for later years (Para 7).
-
Separate notices/orders are appropriate to preserve fairness and prevent inflated liability, higher pre-deposits, and procedural inequity (Paras 7–8).
-
The Single Judge rightly held that cross-examination objections can be raised in adjudication stage; writ court need not intervene (Para 3).
-
Reliance placed on CIT v. Simon Carves Ltd. (1976) 4 SCC 435, emphasizing quasi-judicial fairness by tax officers (Para 10).
Judgment (Paras 8–10)
-
The Division Bench upheld the Single Judge’s order.
-
Composite SCNs covering multiple years are impermissible under Section 74 CGST Act unless the statute itself provides a uniform limitation (as in Customs Act or Central Excise Act).
-
The appeal by the Department was dismissed; authorities were directed to issue separate adjudication orders year-wise.
Between Fine Lines
-
Each financial year under GST has an independent limitation clock under Section 74(10).
-
Issuing a single SCN for multiple years unfairly reduces assessee’s statutory time.
-
Consolidated adjudication inflates demand and appeal pre-deposit – unfair and not envisaged.
-
Cross-examination issues are adjudicatory, not for writ stage.
-
Court reiterated that tax officers must act fairly, not as revenue maximizers.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Case Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| CIT v. Simon Carves Ltd. | (1976) 4 SCC 435 | Tax officers, while quasi-judicial, must act fairly and not as partisan agents of revenue. | Relied upon to stress fairness in GST adjudication. |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




