Home Case Laws Composite GST SCN across Years Held Invalid – Kerala HC

Composite GST SCN across Years Held Invalid – Kerala HC

0
408

Case Title: Joint Commissioner (Intelligence & Enforcement) & Anr. v. M/s Lakshmi Mobile Accessories
Court: High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam
Case No.: W.A. No. 258 of 2025 (against W.P.(C) No. 2911 of 2025)
Date of Judgment: 05.02.2025
Category: GST – Demand under Section 74 – Validity of Consolidated Show Cause Notice
Relevant Provisions: Section 74(1), (2), (9), (10) of the CGST/SGST Act, 2017


Facts of the Case (Paras 2–3)

  • M/s Lakshmi Mobile Accessories received a consolidated show cause notice (SCN) under Section 74 for alleged suppression of turnover for six financial years (2017-18 to 2023-24).

  • The assessee challenged it on grounds that a single consolidated SCN curtailed limitation and reply rights, particularly because the earliest year (2017-18) was expiring on 07.02.2025 under Section 74(10).

  • It was also contended that denial of opportunity for cross-examination of witnesses relied upon in SCN prejudiced them.


Questions in Consideration (Paras 3–4)

  1. Whether a consolidated show cause notice covering multiple financial years under Section 74 CGST Act is valid?

  2. Whether denial of cross-examination of witnesses could be a ground to quash the SCN at notice stage?

  3. Whether separate adjudication orders could be permitted for each year despite one consolidated SCN being issued?


Observations of the Court (Paras 6–10)

  • Section 74 does not mandate issuance of consolidated SCNs; each financial year has an independent limitation period (Para 6–7).

  • Issuing a composite SCN prejudices assessee since limitation for earliest year cuts short the opportunity for later years (Para 7).

  • Separate notices/orders are appropriate to preserve fairness and prevent inflated liability, higher pre-deposits, and procedural inequity (Paras 7–8).

  • The Single Judge rightly held that cross-examination objections can be raised in adjudication stage; writ court need not intervene (Para 3).

  • Reliance placed on CIT v. Simon Carves Ltd. (1976) 4 SCC 435, emphasizing quasi-judicial fairness by tax officers (Para 10).


Judgment (Paras 8–10)

  • The Division Bench upheld the Single Judge’s order.

  • Composite SCNs covering multiple years are impermissible under Section 74 CGST Act unless the statute itself provides a uniform limitation (as in Customs Act or Central Excise Act).

  • The appeal by the Department was dismissed; authorities were directed to issue separate adjudication orders year-wise.


Between Fine Lines

  1. Each financial year under GST has an independent limitation clock under Section 74(10).

  2. Issuing a single SCN for multiple years unfairly reduces assessee’s statutory time.

  3. Consolidated adjudication inflates demand and appeal pre-deposit – unfair and not envisaged.

  4. Cross-examination issues are adjudicatory, not for writ stage.

  5. Court reiterated that tax officers must act fairly, not as revenue maximizers.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
CIT v. Simon Carves Ltd. (1976) 4 SCC 435 Tax officers, while quasi-judicial, must act fairly and not as partisan agents of revenue. Relied upon to stress fairness in GST adjudication.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY