Home Case Laws Part-Adjudication of GST Show Cause Notice Not Permissible: Kerala HC

Part-Adjudication of GST Show Cause Notice Not Permissible: Kerala HC

0
364

Case Title: Deputy Commissioner (Intelligence) & State of Kerala v. Minimol Sabu
Court: High Court of Kerala, Division Bench
Case No.: WA No. 238 of 2025 (arising out of WP(C) No. 40226 of 2024)
Judgment Date: 06.02.2025
Relevant Sections: Section 74 CGST/SGST Act, 2017; Article 226 Constitution of India
Category of Dispute: Challenge to Show Cause Notice / Jurisdiction of Writ Court


Facts of the Case (Paras 2–3)

  • The respondent (assessee), a jeweller dealing in gold, silver, and diamond ornaments, was subjected to a search on 25.05.2023.

  • Data was collected from billing software “Gold Mine.” Based on this, a show cause notice under Section 74 CGST/SGST Act was issued alleging suppression of outward supplies from FY 2017–18 to 2023–24.

  • Tax shortfall of ₹4.88 crore and flood cess ₹11.85 lakh was proposed.

  • The assessee filed a reply alleging discrepancies and contending that part of the turnover belonged to her late husband’s separately registered business.

  • Relying on an earlier HC decision (WP(C) 31434/2024), the assessee sought quashing of the SCN.

  • The Single Judge directed the authorities to first decide the preliminary issue of “separate entity’s turnover” before proceeding further.


Question(s) in Consideration (Para 5)

  • Whether the High Court under Article 226 can direct part-adjudication of issues raised in a Section 74 show cause notice.

  • Whether such directions align with the statutory scheme of CGST/SGST Act.


Observations of the Court (Paras 6–10)

  1. Scheme of Section 74:

    • SCN issued under Section 74(1); adjudication to be completed within 5 years [S.74(9) & (10)].

    • No statutory provision permits adjudication in stages or piecemeal decisions.

  2. Impact of Part-Adjudication:

    • Would delay completion, jeopardise statutory timelines, and harm both Revenue (loss of tax) and assessee (interest accrual).

  3. Writ Court’s Jurisdiction:

    • Article 226 generally should not entertain challenges to SCNs except in cases of total lack of jurisdiction.

    • Cited D.P. Maheswari v. Delhi Administration [(1983) 4 SCC 293] – preliminary issues should not be entertained by courts where statutory adjudication is pending.


Judgment of the Court (Paras 11–12)

  • The Single Judge’s direction of part-adjudication was held unsustainable.

  • Appeal allowed; judgment modified.

  • Assessee directed to appear before proper officer on 10.02.2025; officer to conduct hearing the same day and pass a composite final order by 15.02.2025.


Between Fine Lines (Simplified Outcome)

  • High Court held that GST adjudication under Section 74 cannot be split into stages.

  • Writ jurisdiction under Article 226 cannot be used to quash SCNs or demand preliminary adjudication.

  • Assessee must participate in adjudication before proper officer.

  • Only in cases of lack of jurisdiction can a SCN be challenged before the High Court.

  • Authorities must complete proceedings within statutory timelines.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
D.P. Maheswari v. Delhi Administration (1983) 4 SCC 293 Supreme Court held that courts/tribunals should avoid deciding preliminary issues in isolation when the main dispute remains pending. Applied to taxation law—preliminary objections against SCNs cannot be entertained under Art. 226.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY