Home Case Laws Composite SCN for Multiple Years under Section 74 Held Impermissible

Composite SCN for Multiple Years under Section 74 Held Impermissible

0
406

Court: High Court of Kerala
Case Title: M/s Tharayil Medicals v. Deputy Commissioner, SGST
Petition Number: WA No. 627 of 2025 (Against WP(C) No. 40063 of 2024)
Date of Judgment: 08 April 2025
Category of Dispute: Show Cause Notice under Section 74 – Clubbing of Assessment Years
Relevant Sections: Section 74(1), 74(2), 74(10) of the CGST Act, 2017


Between Fine Lines

The Kerala High Court held that a composite show cause notice (SCN) under Section 74 of CGST Act covering multiple assessment years is legally unsustainable. Each year’s assessment must be dealt with through an independent SCN due to distinct limitation periods and possible differing defences. Issuing one SCN to cover all years can mislead or prejudice the assessee, particularly when timelines differ under Sections 73 and 74. Courts may intervene at SCN stage if the notice is issued without jurisdiction.


Facts of the Case

[Para 2] The appellant, M/s Tharayil Medicals, received a show cause notice (SCN) dated 05.08.2024 under Section 74 of the CGST/SGST Act covering five assessment years (2017-18 to 2021-22), alleging incorrect HSN classification and tax rate application, with a proposed demand of ₹21,13,080.
[Para 2-3] The assessee challenged the notice in WP(C) 40063/2024 relying on Karnataka High Court’s decision in Bangalore Golf Club, which disallowed composite SCNs for multiple years.
[Para 3] The Single Judge dismissed the writ petition, asking the petitioner to reply to the notice and raised issues year-wise before the adjudicating authority.


Question(s) in Consideration

[Para 1, 4, 7] Whether the CGST/SGST Act allows issuance of a single composite SCN under Section 74 covering multiple assessment years, considering the time limitations and separate causes for each year?


Observations of the Court

[Para 9-11]

  • Section 74(1) read with 74(2) and 74(10) prescribes independent timelines for issuance and adjudication of SCNs year-wise.

  • Since each assessment year may involve distinct facts, defences, and limitation periods, a composite SCN is inappropriate.

  • The officer is expected to arrive at subjective satisfaction per year and issue separate SCNs accordingly.
    [Para 12]

  • Issuing a composite SCN may circumvent limitations under Section 73 (which has a 3-year limit and is applicable when fraud is not alleged).

  • Such practice may allow misuse of the extended period of limitation under Section 74, rendering the action colourable and illegal.
    [Para 13-14]

  • Though generally courts discourage interfering with SCNs, an exception exists when SCN is issued without jurisdiction, as in this case.
    [Para 15]

  • The Single Judge erred in not recognising the legal infirmity and relegated the petitioner to reply despite jurisdictional lapse.


Judgment of the Court

[Para 16]

  • Appeal allowed.

  • The composite SCN (Ext.P1) is quashed in respect of AYs 2018–19 to 2021–22.

  • SCN for 2017–18 is upheld, but since limitation lapsed, the time between 08.11.2024 and 08.04.2025 is excluded for computing limitation.

  • Authorities are permitted to issue fresh SCNs for other years separately.

  • Petitioner to file reply within three weeks; authorities to adjudicate 2017–18 within one month thereafter.


Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Joint Commissioner (I&E) v. Lakshmi Mobile Accessories (2025) 171 taxmann.com 214 (Ker) Proper officer cannot issue composite order for multiple years under Sec. 74. Followed
M/s Bangalore Golf Club v. ACCT WP No.16500 of 2024 (Kar. HC) Composite SCN covering multiple years held impermissible. Relied upon
M/s Titan Company Ltd. v. JC of GST WP No. 33164 of 2023 (Madras HC) Composite SCN set aside; direction to issue year-wise SCNs. Relied upon
Riocare India Pvt. Ltd. v. AC CGST (2025) 26 Centax 339 (Bom.) Held that CGST Act does not prohibit composite SCN for multiple years. Distinguished (not followed)
DC of Intelligence v. Minimol Sabu WA No. 238 of 2025 (Ker. HC) Writ petitions against SCNs normally not entertained unless issued without jurisdiction. Exception applied in current case

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY