Home Case Laws High Court Declines Interference: ITC Fraud Allegations to be Addressed via Statutory...

High Court Declines Interference: ITC Fraud Allegations to be Addressed via Statutory Appeal

0
327

Case Details

  • Case Title: Shivam Iron Store Through Proprietor Jagdish Rai Bansal v. Union of India & Anr.

  • Court: High Court of Delhi

  • Petition Number: W.P.(C) 4528/2025

  • Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC) – Fraud Allegation, Natural Justice

  • Date of Judgment: 08 April 2025

  • Relevant Sections: Section 67 and Section 107 of CGST Act, 2017

  • Bench: Justice Prathiba M. Singh and Justice Rajneesh Kumar Gupta


Facts of the Case (Para 2–12)

  1. The petitioner challenged the Order-in-Original dated 03.02.2025 passed by the Additional Commissioner, CGST Delhi-West, following a SCN issued on 24.07.2024, alleging fraudulent availment and circulation of Input Tax Credit (ITC) through other entities. (Para 2–3)

  2. During a search on 30.11.2022, cash of ₹72 lakhs was seized, and the petitioner was arrested but later granted bail. (Para 4–5)

  3. In a previous writ (W.P.(C) 16677/2023), the Court ordered the refund of seized cash, holding that cash is not “goods” under Section 67 CGST Act. (Para 5)

  4. The petitioner claimed non-receipt of Relied Upon Documents (RUDs) and non-grant of personal hearing, despite submitting a preliminary reply on 17.12.2024. (Para 6–8)

  5. Respondents argued that RUDs were supplied via CD on 19.07.2024 and virtual hearing links were sent. (Para 10–12)


Question(s) in Consideration (Para 13–14, 22–23)

  • Whether the Order-in-Original suffered from breach of principles of natural justice due to non-supply of relied upon documents and denial of hearing?

  • Whether a writ petition is maintainable in light of an available appellate remedy under Section 107 of the CGST Act?


Observations of the Court (Para 16–24)

  1. The Court found the petitioner’s email communications vague and lacking specificity regarding the allegedly missing RUDs. (Para 16–17)

  2. RUDs were in fact enclosed in the CD with the show cause notice as per record. (Para 18)

  3. Despite being aware, the petitioner did not diligently participate in hearings; the adjudicating authority noted absence during the final hearing. (Para 21–22)

  4. No violation of natural justice or jurisdictional error was found. (Para 23)

  5. Court emphasized that filing writs instead of statutory appeals under Section 107 is not encouraged unless exceptional circumstances exist. (Para 14–15)


Judgment of the Court (Para 24–27)

  • The Court dismissed the writ petition, holding that the petitioner had effective alternative remedy under Section 107 of CGST Act.

  • Petitioners were directed to approach the appellate authority, which shall consider any plea regarding pre-deposit in accordance with law. (Para 26–27)


Between Fine Lines

  1. Cash cannot be seized as “goods” under Section 67 of CGST Act—previously affirmed by Court.

  2. RUDs supplied via CD were held sufficient; vague email protests lacked merit.

  3. Absence in hearings weakened the petitioner’s plea of natural justice violation.

  4. Writ jurisdiction cannot replace statutory appellate remedies unless justice is gravely compromised.

  5. The petitioner can still avail the appeal route under Section 107 and make submissions about pre-deposit due to pending refund.


Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
K.M. Food Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. Director General (DGGI) 2024:DHC:1081-DB Held that cash is not “goods” and hence cannot be seized under Section 67. Relief granted; cash seizure held invalid

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY