Case Title: M/s. Krishna Enterprise v. Union of India & Ors.
Court: High Court of Gujarat, Ahmedabad
Petition Number: R/Special Civil Application No. 4071 of 2025
Judgment Date: 16.04.2025
Category of Dispute: Confiscation of Goods & Conveyance (Section 129 & 130 GST)
Relevant Sections: Section 129, Section 130, Section 107 CGST Act; Rule 109A CGST Rules
Neutral Citation: 2025:GUJHC:22750-DB
Facts of the Case (Paras 2–3.9)
-
The petitioner purchased 25,005 Kgs of Remelted Lead Ingots from M/s. Sunrise Enterprises (Invoice dated 23.10.2024) and transported them with an e-way bill (Para 3).
-
The truck was intercepted on 24.10.2024 under Section 129 CGST/SGST Act; physical verification and detention orders were issued in MOV-2 and MOV-6 (Paras 3, 3.1).
-
Show-cause notice (MOV-10) was issued on 11.11.2024 alleging that M/s. Sunrise Enterprises was a non-existent entity issuing fake invoices (Para 3.1).
-
Petitioner consented to pay 200% penalty (₹15,75,315) under protest for release of goods (Para 3.2).
-
Order under Section 130 (MOV-11) dated 20.11.2024 was passed (Para 3.3).
-
Petitioner requested uploading of the order for appeal purposes and filed appeal on 18.02.2025 before Commissioner (Appeals), Hyderabad (Paras 3.4–3.7).
-
Despite appeal, respondents issued auction notice. Petitioner sought provisional release but no relief was given, leading to filing of present writ petition (Paras 3.8–3.9).
Questions in Consideration (Paras 4–5)
-
Whether writ petition under Article 226 is maintainable when the petitioner has already filed appeal under Section 107 of CGST Act?
-
Whether provisional release of goods and withdrawal of auction notice should be directed when penalty is paid under protest?
-
Whether confiscation under Section 130 is valid when supplier is found to be a non-existent/fake entity?
Observations of the Court (Paras 7–10)
-
The petitioner already preferred appeal under Section 107; hence, writ petition is not maintainable for same relief (Para 7).
-
Provisional release issue is already pending before appellate authority; hence, High Court cannot interfere (Para 8).
-
Prima facie findings show that supplier (M/s. Sunrise Enterprises) is a non-existent entity; thus, confiscation proceedings under Section 130 are justified (Paras 9–10).
-
Neither supplier nor transporter sought release of goods, further reinforcing the irregularity (Para 9).
Judgment of the Court (Para 11)
-
The High Court dismissed the writ petition, holding that:
-
No interference is warranted in confiscation proceedings.
-
Observations are prima facie and final adjudication lies with appellate authority.
-
-
Petition declared devoid of merit.
Between Fine Lines (Simplified Outcome in 5 Lines)
The High Court refused to interfere since the petitioner had already filed an appeal.
Confiscation proceedings were upheld as the supplier was a non-existent/fake entity.
Auction and provisional release matters must be dealt with at appellate level.
Writ jurisdiction cannot be used as an alternate remedy when statutory appeal exists.
The petition was dismissed, leaving decision to Commissioner (Appeals).
Summary of Referred Cases
(No external case law referred in the judgment; findings are based on statutory interpretation and facts.)
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




