Home Case Laws RMPU Classification Dispute – Delhi HC Keeps Adjudication Open Pending Writ Outcome

RMPU Classification Dispute – Delhi HC Keeps Adjudication Open Pending Writ Outcome

0
396

Case Title: M/s Stesalit Limited & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors.
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition Number: W.P.(C) 3138/2025 & CM APPLs. 14824/2025, 21403/2025, 21404/2025
Date of Judgment: 16 April 2025
Category of Dispute: Classification under GST
Relevant Sections: Section 9, Section 103(2), Section 104(1) CGST Act, 2017; Notification No. 01/2017-CT (Rate); Section Notes 2 & 3 of Section XVII, Customs Tariff Act, 1975.


Facts of the Case (Paras 3–16)

  • Petitioners (M/s Stesalit Ltd. & Alok Singhal) challenged Circular No. 235/2024-GST dated 11.10.2024 issued by the Ministry of Finance, clarifying that Roof Mounted Package Units (RMPU) air conditioning machines for railways should be classified under HSN 8415 (28% GST) instead of HSN 8607 (18% GST).

  • Petitioners argued that RMPUs have always been classified under HSN 8607, attracting 18% GST, and contracts with Indian Railways were executed on this basis. A sudden reclassification to HSN 8415 would disrupt their business.

  • Petitioners relied on Advance Rulings by AARs in Uttar Pradesh (14.02.2020), Madhya Pradesh, and Himachal Pradesh (11.04.2022), all of which classified RMPUs under HSN 8607.


Question(s) in Consideration (Paras 10–14)

  1. Whether RMPUs used in railways are classifiable under HSN 8607 (18% GST) or HSN 8415 (28% GST)?

  2. Whether the Circular of October 2024 can override statutory adjudication powers and advance rulings?


Observations of Court (Paras 15–21)

  • The Court noted that multiple AARs, including the jurisdictional Himachal Pradesh AAR, had consistently held RMPUs to fall under HSN 8607.

  • Petitioners had also received a Show Cause Notice dated 12.03.2025 (received on 19.03.2025) demanding tax based on the circular.

  • The Court observed that the adjudication process should not be pre-empted by the circular; the Adjudicating Authority must consider advance rulings, the petitioners’ reply, and the circular before passing any order.


Judgment of Court (Paras 20–23)

  • Petitioners directed to file reply to SCN within 30 days from 16.04.2025.

  • Adjudicating Authority to decide classification issue independently, considering rulings and submissions, but final order will be subject to outcome of this writ petition.

  • Importantly, the Court held that the final order shall not be given effect without further orders of the Court.

  • Case listed for further hearing on 9 May 2025.


Between Fine Lines (Simplified Summary)

  • The dispute is over whether railway AC units (RMPUs) attract 18% or 28% GST.

  • Govt. circular pushed them into 28% slab, while prior rulings classified them at 18%.

  • Court allowed adjudication to proceed but kept the writ petition alive.

  • Adjudicating Authority must consider all material and cannot blindly follow the circular.

  • Any final demand will remain on hold until the writ is decided.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case/Authority Citation / Date Summary Verdict
AAR Uttar Pradesh 14.02.2020 Classified RMPUs, designed exclusively for railways, under HSN 8607. Ruled in favour of 18% GST.
AAR Himachal Pradesh 11.04.2022 Jurisdictional AAR for petitioner; held RMPUs fall under HSN 8607. Ruled in favour of 18% GST.
AAR Madhya Pradesh Date not specified Similar ruling, classifying RMPUs under HSN 8607. Ruled in favour of 18% GST.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY