Home Q&A Correct GST Classification on Bundled Supply of Solar Enabled Generators and Food...

Correct GST Classification on Bundled Supply of Solar Enabled Generators and Food Supplied to Contract Labourers

0
495

Question: Please suggest replies to the following queries:

  1. Generators are taxable @ 18% & the solar power generating systems are taxable @ 5%. Now, lot of companies are selling both together as bundled in composite supply and treating the same as Solar enabled generators by which they are charging 5% on the whole product which includes Generator, Module & connecting Wires. Is this a correct proposition?
  2. Manufacturing company is taking Contract Labour Services from let us say Co X. Now the Mfr Co is providing food to the Labourers for which they are charging certain amount to Co X, which gets adjusted against the Contract Labour Services invoices However, the mfr co is not charging GST on the Food amount being adjusted against such invoice. Is this a correct proposition or should mfr co charge the GST as it relates to supply of food services to Co. X.

 

Answer: A supply of renewable goods along with services of installation is a bundled composite supply, which is now a settled position. Accordingly, such supply will be considered as a works contract as it relates to an immovable property.  The composite supply is taxable at the rate of 18% as applicable to works contract under HSN 9954. Since most of the renewable devices and their parts are taxable at 5 percent under Notification No. 1/2017-Central Tax(Rate), GST Council in its 31st council meeting recommended that the value of such composite supply should be divided between its components of goods and services and applicable taxes should be levied at such rates as applicable on those goods and services. Accordingly, notifications of rates of both goods and services were amended to incorporate the said change.  70% of the value of such supply is attributed towards goods taxable at the rate of 5% vide entry 234 of Rate Notification and balance 30% is made taxable as value of services under entry 38 of Notification No.11/2017 – Central Tax (Rate). It is important to note that no such power under the law is available to the government to artificially bifurcate the value of a composite supply between goods and services and, therefore, the division of value between goods and services artificially is ultra virus the provisions of the CGST Act. However, notwithstanding the above position, even if it is accepted that such division of value is within the competence of the Government, still the Notification does not mention the very crucial words which are present in the recommendation of the GST Council minutes of its 31st Council meeting which said that the value shall be applicable in case of tax rate on EPC supply of solar power generating system and no other supplies can be made part of such supplies.

Thus, in respect of your question, supplies by way of generators (diesel) are also clubbed as part of this bundled supply. In my humble opinion, such bundled supply will not qualify as a composite supply within the purview of value bifurcation as provided in entry 234. The same may be treated as mixed supply and shall be taxable as the supply of that particular supply which attracts the highest rate of tax.

LEAVE A REPLY