Question: Supply of ice creams and other addons in a franchisee –
- where no seating arrangement is there
- where air-conditioned seating arrangement is there for which rent is being paid by the supplier of composite supply.
What is the principal supply – Ice-cream or restaurant service? Can one bypass/avoid the application of the concept of ‘composite supply’ if they enter into two separate contracts for the two supplies they intend to make? Should the concept of composite supply be understood with respect to two taxable supplies or with respect to two persons? For example, where car supplier is a different person and RTO/insurance/registration service is supplied by a different person. Commercially/Normally, these two supplies when supplied by a single person constitute a composite supply.
Answer: The differentiation between the supply of goods (eatables) as supply of food or as a part of composite supply of restaurants services has been decided in the decision of Kundan Misthan Bhandar [[2019] 105 taxmann.com 364 (AAAR-UTTARAKHAND)]. It was held that “all goods which are supplied to customers through sweetshop counter have no direct or indirect nexus with restaurant service. Anyone can come and purchase any item of any quantity from the counter without visiting the restaurant. The billings of such sales are also done separately. Thus, such sales, by no stretch of imagination, can be clubbed with restaurant service.”
It is important to understand that Supply of restaurant services is primarily the supply of service and as part of such services, goods, being food or any other article for human consumption or any drink, are supplied to the consumer. Unless the service is established, the supply of food cannot constitute a restaurants service. The restaurants service is established when various services are supplied to the customer including service of food such as air conditioning, sitting arrangement, ambience etc. and, therefore, when mere food is sold to the customer over the counter, such supply will constitute a supply of food i.e. goods and not supply of restaurant service.
In case of composite supply, one has to understand that there is always a principal supply without which the other incidental supplies would not have been economically/commercially practical for the supplier to provide to the buyer. One must refer to the decision of European Court of Justice in the case of Card Protection Plan whereby it has been held that a supply should be held as composite supply, if it does not constitute for customers an aim in itself, but a means of better enjoying the principal service supplied. One must notice that composite supply does not need a single price, even two or more supplies having distinct prices could satisfy the characteristics of being a composite supply. The criteria of a single price is inherent in the definition of mixed supply. In case of any supply having distinct prices, the first presumption is that those supplies are independent supplies. However, if it can be established that those supplies are not economically viable to be provided distinctively if the principal supply is not given, and such services are offered in such bundled manner by the trade, then, even when they are having different prices they will be considered as a composite supply.



