Home Updates Delhi HC: Judges’ Statutory Allowances Prima Facie Remain Outside Salary Income Under...

Delhi HC: Judges’ Statutory Allowances Prima Facie Remain Outside Salary Income Under New Tax Regime

0
102

The Delhi High Court, in Delhi Tax Bar Association through its Secretary K.G. Bansal v. Union of India & Anr., has examined an important issue concerning the treatment of specified allowances and perquisites available to Judges of the High Courts and Supreme Court when income-tax returns are filed under the new tax regime. The writ petition challenges the CBDT Office Memorandum dated 12 September 2025 concerning the applicability of Section 115BAC of the Income-tax Act, 1961 to such allowances.

The petitioner contended that Section 22D of the High Court Judges (Salaries and Conditions of Service) Act, 1954 and Section 23D of the corresponding legislation governing Supreme Court Judges operate independently of ordinary deductions and exemptions under the Income-tax Act. According to the petitioner, the specified benefits are statutorily excluded from computation of income chargeable under the head “Salaries” and therefore cannot become taxable merely because an assessee opts for the new tax regime.

Statutory Exclusion Distinguished from Tax Exemption

Section 22D covers, among other things, the value of rent-free official residence or the corresponding allowance, conveyance facilities, sumptuary allowance and leave travel concession provided to a Judge and members of the Judge’s family. The provision expressly states, notwithstanding anything contained in the Income-tax Act, that these amounts shall not be included in the computation of income chargeable under the head “Salaries”.

At the interim stage, the Delhi High Court expressed the prima facie view that the non-obstante clauses contained in Sections 22D and 23D give those provisions overriding effect over the Income-tax Act, including Section 115BAC. The Court further observed that an amount which is not included in income at the stage of computation cannot ordinarily be characterised as an “exemption” or “deduction” for the purposes of restrictions associated with Section 115BAC.

This distinction is central to the controversy. The case concerns whether the statutory exclusion granted to specified judicial allowances survives the new tax regime even though Section 115BAC generally operates on the basis of concessional tax rates accompanied by restrictions on several deductions and exemptions.

Challenge to CBDT Office Memorandum

The petitioner challenged the CBDT Office Memorandum dated 12 September 2025 on the ground that it treated allowances such as rent-free official residence, conveyance facilities, sumptuary allowance and leave travel concession as unavailable for exclusion when a Judge opts for the new tax regime. It was also argued that the treatment contemplated by the Office Memorandum could adversely affect the statutory service conditions attached to judicial office.

The petitioner additionally raised a practical difficulty concerning the income-tax return utility, submitting that no specific facility was available under the new regime for separately reflecting these statutory exclusions.

Interim Direction for Filing Income-Tax Returns

Pending consideration of the writ petition, the High Court permitted Judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts to file their income-tax returns or revised returns by reflecting allowances covered by Sections 22D and 23D under the category “Receipts not in the nature of income”. The Court indicated that this may be done through the “Exempt Income” section of the dashboard, followed by “Other Incomes” and the relevant sub-category.

Importantly, the Court directed that returns filed in this manner shall not be processed or proceeded with until further orders. The direction is interim in nature and does not amount to a final determination of the constitutional or statutory issues raised in the petition.

Why This Judgment Matters

The proceeding raises a significant question concerning the interaction between a special statutory provision containing a non-obstante clause and the general framework of the new income-tax regime. It also highlights the legal difference between an amount that is excluded at the computation stage and an amount that forms part of income but is subsequently allowed as an exemption or deduction.

For tax professionals, the matter is particularly relevant to the interpretation of Section 115BAC, the legal effect of overriding provisions contained in special legislation, and the manner in which statutory exclusions should be accommodated in return-filing utilities.

The Court has presently recorded only a prima facie view and granted interim protection. The respondents were granted time to file their reply, and the matter was directed to be listed on 3 September 2026. Accordingly, the final legal position remains subject to further orders of the Delhi High Court.

 

Download

LEAVE A REPLY