The Supreme Court of India, in The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax-2 & Anr. v. M/s LTI Mindtree Ltd., declined to entertain the Revenue’s Special Leave Petition arising from the Karnataka High Court’s judgment dated 4 September 2025 in ITA No. 147/2024. The matter was considered by a Bench comprising Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi on 4 August 2026.
The petition before the Supreme Court was registered as Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No. 40271/2026. At the outset, the Court condoned the delay in filing the petition. However, having regard to the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, the Bench stated that it was not inclined to entertain the Special Leave Petition and accordingly dismissed it.
Importantly, while dismissing the Revenue’s petition, the Supreme Court expressly recorded that the “question of law, if any, is kept open.” This qualification is significant because the dismissal does not amount to an express adjudication or affirmation by the Supreme Court of any broader legal proposition that may have arisen from the underlying Karnataka High Court judgment.
Accordingly, the order is essentially confined to the particular facts and circumstances before the Court. The Supreme Court did not examine or determine the substantive question of law on merits. Tax professionals should therefore distinguish between the dismissal of the Revenue’s SLP in this individual matter and a binding pronouncement by the Supreme Court on the underlying legal issue.
The Court also directed that all pending applications, if any, would stand disposed of.
Key Legal Takeaway
The Supreme Court’s dismissal of an SLP on the peculiar facts and circumstances of a case, coupled with an express statement that the question of law is kept open, leaves the underlying legal issue available for consideration in an appropriate future case. The present order should therefore not be treated as a final Supreme Court ruling on the substantive question of law involved.




