Hindustan Construction Company Ltd. v. Union of India
High Court of Rajasthan
D.B. Civil Writ Petition Nos. 12419 & 12416 of 2022
Category: Interest & Penalty on delayed tax payment
Date of Judgement: 15 December 2022
Relevant Section: Section 75(6) of the CGST Act, 2017
Facts of the Case
(Para 1-3)
The petitioner challenged two orders (Nos. 42 and 43 dated 24.06.2022) passed by the Joint Commissioner, SGST, Circle Nimbaheda, imposing interest and penalty for delayed tax payment. The petitioner submitted that although a detailed reply to the show cause notice was filed and a request for personal hearing made, the adjudication orders were passed without granting an opportunity for such hearing and without considering the written reply.
(Para 5)
The respondent officer claimed the notice for the hearing was dispatched and delivered on a Saturday (18.06.2022) and recorded in the order-sheet on 30.05.2022, so no separate notice was needed. However, the petitioner’s representative did not appear on 22.06.2022.
Question(s) in Consideration
(Para 2, 9)
- Whether the impugned assessment orders violated Section 75(6) of the CGST Act by failing to record the basis and facts of the decision?
- Whether the orders were passed in breach of the principles of natural justice due to the absence of oral hearing and non-consideration of written submissions?
Observation of the Court
(Para 9)
The Court found that the impugned orders were “non-speaking” and sketchy, without considering the detailed written reply of the petitioner. The officer failed to comply with Section 75(6) of the CGST Act which mandates setting out relevant facts and reasoning in the final order. This amounted to non-application of mind and denial of reasonable opportunity.
(Para 6)
The petitioner’s counsel admitted the absence of mala fides but pressed for an opportunity for oral submissions and a fresh reasoned order.
Judgement of the Court
(Para 10-13)
The High Court quashed and set aside the impugned orders for violating Section 75(6) of the CGST Act and principles of natural justice. The Joint Commissioner was directed to provide the petitioner an opportunity of hearing on 22.12.2022 and pass a fresh reasoned order thereafter. The show cause notice against the officer was discharged. The writ petitions were allowed without costs
Between Fine Lines
The Court reasserted that GST adjudication orders must be reasoned and show due application of mind. Ignoring the taxpayer’s written submissions, even if a hearing date was communicated, is a violation of the CGST Act. The decision reinforces procedural fairness, mandating a fair hearing and reasoned conclusion before raising demand for interest or penalty.
Summary of Referred Cases
No external judicial precedents were cited in this judgment. The case was decided solely on statutory interpretation and principles of natural justice.
Takeaway:
“No Demand Without Reason: Speaking Order is a Statutory Mandate Under GST”




