Case Title: Refex Industries Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise
Court: High Court of Madras
Petition Numbers: W.P. Nos. 23360 & 23361 of 2019; WMP Nos. 23106 & 23108 of 2019
Category of Dispute: Interest Liability on Delayed GST Payment (Input Tax Credit)
Date of Judgment: 06 January 2020
Relevant Section: Section 50 of the CGST Act, 2017
Takeaway: “No Interest on What You Already Hold” – Clarifying Interest Applicability on ITC Adjustments
Facts of the Case (Paras 1–4)
Refex Industries Ltd., registered under the CGST Act, filed GSTR returns for FY 2017–18 belatedly. The Assistant Commissioner issued communications in May 2019 demanding interest @18% under Section 50 on the delayed remittance of tax, amounting to ₹11,65,982 (W.P. No. 23360/2019) and ₹23,62,746 (W.P. No. 23361/2019). Demand notices were issued to banks for recovery.
Petitioners contended that they had sufficient Input Tax Credit (ITC) throughout the relevant period and had paid the balance cash component of tax along with proportionate interest. Hence, interest should only apply to the belated cash portion: ₹1,21,701 and ₹1,25,751 respectively.
Questions in Consideration (Paras 4, 8–10)
- Is interest under Section 50 of the CGST Act automatically applicable even when the tax liability is discharged through available ITC?
- Can interest be levied on the ITC portion when such credit was continuously available with the Department?
Observation of the Court (Paras 5–16)
- A previous case (W.P. No. 15978 of 2019) had led to divergent views among a Division Bench and was finally decided by a Third Judge (Para 6–8). That decision held that while interest liability is automatic, quantification requires a factual assessment.
- The present case, however, raised a purely legal question: whether interest applies to ITC already available with the Department (Para 9).
- The Court observed that ITC reflects funds already available to the Government. Hence, there is no “deprivation” or “delay” justifying interest on that portion (Paras 11–12).
- The 2019 amendment to Section 50(1) (effective 01.08.2019), stating that interest applies only to cash ledger payments, was held to be clarificatory and retrospective (Para 15).
- Telangana High Court’s view in Megha Engineering (2019) was distinguished because it was delivered before the statutory amendment (Para 16).
Judgment of the Court (Para 17)
The Madras High Court allowed the writ petitions and set aside the interest demand notices issued by the department. It held that interest under Section 50 is not leviable on the portion of tax paid via available ITC. No costs were imposed.
Between Fine Lines
- Interest under Section 50 of the CGST Act applies only to delayed cash payments, not on tax adjusted through available ITC.
- The retrospective amendment to Section 50(1) clarifies this position.
- ITC, being a credit already with the Department, does not represent a loss or delay of revenue.
- The judgment distinguishes between legal and factual objections—this case involved a legal objection, thus decided without remand.
- This judgment provides relief to assessees facing coercive recovery on ITC-adjusted tax delays.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Megha Engineering and Infrastructures Ltd. v. Commr. of Central Tax | [2019] 104 taxmann.com 393 / 73 GST 787 (Telangana HC) | Held interest is payable on entire tax liability including ITC due to absence of statutory amendment at that time | Distinguished by Madras HC due to subsequent statutory amendment |
| CIT v. Anjum M.H. Ghaswala | [2001] 252 ITR 1 (SC) | Held that interest under Income-tax Act for delayed tax payments is compensatory and hence mandatory | Applied to support the compensatory nature of interest under GST |
| Refex (Previous Round – W.P. No. 15978/2019) | Not separately cited | High Court had remanded for factual quantification of interest post objection | Distinguished as the present case involved pure legal issue |




