Home Case Laws Department cannot arbitrarily reject refund by stating reasons which were not mentioned...

Department cannot arbitrarily reject refund by stating reasons which were not mentioned under law.

0
549

Case Title: Mahajan Fabrics (P.) Ltd. vs. Commissioner, Central Goods and Services Tax

Court: High Court of Delhi

Petition No.: W.P.(C) No. 6727 of 2022

Category: Refund – Unutilized Input Tax Credit (ITC)

Date of Judgement: 06 February 2023

Relevant Sections: Section 54, Section 16, Section 107(2) of the CGST Act, 2017; Rule 89(1) of CGST Rules, 2017

 

Facts of the Case

[Para 1–5]

  • Mahajan Fabrics (P.) Ltd. filed for refund of unutilized ITC under Section 54 read with Rule 89(1). The Assistant Commissioner sanctioned ₹22,32,502 (₹16,22,489 CGST + ₹6,10,013 SGST) via Order-in-Original dated 12.09.2019.
  • The Commissioner reviewed the order under Section 107(2) and directed an appeal, claiming two vehicle numbers in the invoices were not registered on the e-vahan portal, casting doubt on the genuineness of 126 invoices.

[Para 6–7]

  • Only 2 out of 126 invoices were scrutinized; based on e-vahan non-verification of these, the entire refund was termed dubious.

[Para 8–9]

  • Appellate Authority acknowledged that the vehicles were in fact registered but still denied refund, stating petitioner failed to prove receipt of goods for remaining 124 invoices due to absence of vehicle registration evidence.

 

Question(s) in Consideration

[Para 10–13]

  • Whether the refund can be denied merely due to alleged non-verification of vehicle details in only two invoices?
  • Whether Section 16 requires vehicle registration proof on e-vahan portal to substantiate receipt of goods?

Observations of the Court

[Para 14–18]

  • There is no legal requirement under Section 16 to submit vehicle registration details on e-vahan.
  • Explanation to Section 16(2)(b) presumes receipt of goods when delivered by supplier or its agent.
  • The Appellate Authority admitted the two scrutinized vehicles were valid but still relied on an erroneous presumption for other invoices.
  • The foundational basis of the review order (that the vehicles were unregistered) was proved false. No evidence was found disputing receipt of goods.

Judgement of the Court

[Para 19–21]

  • The High Court allowed the writ petition.
  • The impugned appellate order dated 30.12.2021 was quashed.
  • Revenue was directed to refund the amount sanctioned originally.
  • No costs were imposed.

Between Fine Lines

This case confirms that refund of ITC cannot be denied merely on presumptions or partial scrutiny. Once the primary allegation forming the basis of denial is disproved, no additional burden lies on the assessee. There is no legal compulsion to furnish e-vahan records for each vehicle used. Return filing and invoice details suffice unless specifically challenged with evidence.

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
None cited explicitly – The judgement does not reference or rely on precedent cases. –

 

Takeaway

“Scrutiny Without Substance – When Presumption Cannot Override Proof”

LEAVE A REPLY