Case Title: Deem Distributors (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India
Court: High Court of Telangana
Petition No.: Writ Petition No. 7063 of 2021, I.A. No. 2 of 2021
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit
Date of Judgement: 3rd August 2021
Relevant Sections: Section 74(1), 74(5), and 70 of CGST Act, 2017
Takeaway: “No Demand Without Due Process – Pre-SCN Recovery Declared Arbitrary”
Facts of the Case
[¶ 1-3] The petitioner, Deem Distributors (P.) Ltd., engaged in the trade of ferrous and steel products, was issued a letter dated 25.04.2019 by the GST authorities, alleging availing of fraudulent Input Tax Credit (ITC) based on fake invoices from fictitious suppliers. It was alleged that goods were not actually received.
[¶ 4] Though summons were issued under Section 70 of the CGST Act, no notice under Section 74(1) had yet been issued, and investigations remained incomplete.
[¶ 5-7] The petitioner challenged coercive demands made by the authorities at the investigation stage, alleging violation of Articles 14 and 300-A of the Constitution. It had made payments of ₹10 lakh and ₹25 lakh in April and September 2019 respectively to avoid further coercion.
Questions in Consideration
[¶ 5-7, ¶ 17-22]
- Can the tax authorities demand reversal of ITC and payment of tax, interest, and penalty during investigation, without issuing a notice under Section 74(1) of the CGST Act?
- Does Section 74(5) permit coercive recovery without determination of liability through proper enquiry?
- Is any advisory or intimation tantamount to a lawful demand under the Act?
Observations of the Court
[¶ 15-16] The Court interpreted Section 74 in detail and clarified that:
- A notice under Section 74(1) is mandatory before any demand can be enforced.
- Section 74(5) provides a voluntary option to the assessee to pay tax and does not empower the department to raise any demand before determination.
[¶ 17-22] The respondents’ actions in issuing letters and advisories during an ongoing investigation, and before issuance of any show-cause notice under Section 74(1), were held to be beyond jurisdiction and arbitrary. - There was no authority under the Act to raise demands without following due procedure.
- Investigations must culminate in a determination after issuing SCN and providing opportunity of hearing.
Judgement of the Court
[¶ 23-26]
- The writ petition was allowed.
- The respondents were restrained from coercing the petitioner to make any payment without first issuing a notice under Section 74(1) and following due procedure.
- The amount of ₹35,00,000 already paid by the petitioner was directed to be refunded with interest at 7% per annum within 4 weeks.
- Authorities were permitted to continue with the investigation, but strictly in accordance with the law.
Between Fine Lines
- Authorities cannot demand reversal of ITC or payment of tax without completing investigation and issuing a notice under Section 74(1).
- Section 74(5) gives only an option to the assessee and not a right to the department to raise a demand.
- Any pre-determination coercion violates constitutional protections and due process.
- Refunds must be granted where money is recovered without legal authority.
- Investigation may proceed, but demands must follow the prescribed statutory procedure.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Case Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| No cases explicitly cited | N.A. | The judgement is primarily based on interpretation of Section 74 of CGST Act and does not cite any precedent case law. | N.A. |




