Case Title: Sahil Enterprises v. Union of India
Court: High Court of Tripura
Petition No.: WP(C) No. 531 of 2021
Relevant Section: Section 16(2)(c) of CGST Act, 2017
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit
Date of Judgment: 9 August 2021
Relevant Sections: Section 16(2)(c), Section 41, Section 43A of CGST Act, 2017
Facts of the Case
- The petitioner, Sahil Enterprises, challenged the constitutional validity of Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act, 2017 [Para 1].
- This section mandates that ITC can only be claimed if the tax charged on supply has actually been paid to the Government by the supplier [Para 1].
- The petitioner contended that after paying the tax to the supplier, it cannot be held responsible if the supplier defaults in depositing the tax with the Government [Para 1].
- The petitioner argued that denying ITC under such circumstances amounts to double taxation and violates Articles 14, 19(1)(g), and 300A of the Constitution [Para 1].
- It was also pointed out that similar provisions in earlier tax regimes were either read down or struck down by various High Courts [Para 2].
- Additionally, the petitioner’s ITC account was placed under attachment since 21-05-2020 due to the default of the supplier, which the petitioner argued should be lifted as more than one year had passed, violating provisions of the CGST Act [Para 3].
Questions in Consideration
- Whether Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act, 2017 is constitutionally valid? [Para 1]
- Whether ITC can be denied to a bona fide purchaser for the default of the supplier in paying the tax to the Government? [Para 1, 2]
- Whether the department can continue attachment of the ITC account beyond one year under the CGST Act? [Para 3]
Observations of the Court
- The court took cognizance of the issue, noting that the matter involved the vires of parliamentary legislation and affected constitutional rights [Para 4].
- The Court observed that similar provisions had been challenged in other High Courts, and there existed a pattern of judicial interventions where such provisions were either read down or struck down when the purchaser acted in good faith [Para 2].
- It acknowledged that the continued attachment of ITC account beyond one year raised a legal issue requiring adjudication [Para 3].
Judgment of the Court
- The Court admitted the writ petition by issuing a rule and directed notice to the Attorney General due to the constitutional nature of the challenge [Para 4].
- The Court scheduled a returnable date for considering interim relief regarding removal of attachment of ITC account to 23-08-2021 [Para 5].
- Notices were waived by the respective counsels for the respondents including the Union of India and the Attorney General [Para 5].
Between Fine Lines
- A taxpayer cannot be punished for the supplier’s default after paying tax.
- Court acknowledged potential unconstitutionality in burdening buyers with supplier’s failure.
- Legal bar on extended attachment beyond one year under CGST Act was noted.
- The case adds to the growing legal scrutiny against Section 16(2)(c) across India.
- Interim relief on ITC account attachment was slated for further hearing.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Various High Court judgments under pre-GST regime | Not individually cited | Courts have either read down similar provisions or declared them unconstitutional if the buyer acted in good faith and supplier defaulted | Held that denial of credit without fault of purchaser is arbitrary and unconstitutional |




