Case Title: Brij Mohan Mangla v. Union of India
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition No.: W.P.(C) No. 14234 of 2022
Category of Dispute: Refund – Inverted Duty Structure
Date of Judgment: 23 February 2023
Relevant Sections: Section 54(3) of CGST Act, 2017
Coram: Vibhu Bakhru & Amit Mahajan, JJ.
Facts of the Case
[¶2-5] The petitioner, engaged in manufacturing liquid printing inks, was registered under CGST Act with a Delhi GSTIN. For the period May–December 2019, due to inverted duty structure, ITC accumulation of ₹74,02,337 occurred.
[¶6] He filed six refund claims. However, GST authorities issued SCNs (Form RFD-08), citing physical non-existence at registered premises and cancellation of registration w.e.f. 19-2-2021.
[¶7] Petitioner clarified that he had shifted to Haryana only later.
[¶8] Authorities rejected claims stating he wasn’t a “registered person” under Section 54(3).
[¶9] On appeal, Joint Commissioner (Appeals) allowed all appeals on 20-9-2021, confirming petitioner’s registration at the time of refund application and entitlement under law.
[¶10-11,16] Despite this, refund applications were not processed; instead, deficiency memos were repeatedly issued, raising settled issues again.
[¶12-14] Separately, cancellation of GST registration was also overturned in appeal on 20-10-2021.
Questions in Consideration
[¶1, 17-20]
- Whether the Department can withhold refunds sanctioned by the Appellate Authority merely because it intends to file an appeal.
- Whether refund claims can be denied on the basis of earlier registration cancellation when such cancellation has been overturned.
Observations of the Court
[¶21-23]
- Respondents had not filed appeals against the Appellate Orders despite the lapse of prescribed time.
- No stay was obtained against appellate orders.
- Respondents’ refusal to implement appellate orders solely on intent to appeal is untenable and undermines rule of law.
[¶24]
- Cited Saurabh Singal v. CGST [2023] 148 taxmann.com 294: where similar compliance with appellate orders was directed irrespective of proposed appeal.
Judgment of the Court
[¶25-27]
- Petition allowed.
- Respondents directed to process refund claims along with interest without delay.
- Clarified that the Department may still pursue legal remedies against appellate orders, but cannot withhold refunds without stay.
Between Fine Lines
- Even if the Department plans to file an appeal, it must honour appellate authority decisions unless stayed.
- Refunds cannot be denied based on reversed registration cancellation.
- A taxpayer’s entitlement under Section 54(3) remains intact if registration was valid at the time of claim.
- Bureaucratic delay tactics are not permissible under the law.
- Court reaffirmed judicial discipline and respect for appellate hierarchy.
Summary of Referred Cases
| S. No. | Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| 1 | Saurabh Singal v. CGST | [2023] 148 taxmann.com 294 | Court directed implementation of appellate order despite appeal being proposed. | Refund directed to be processed. |
Takeaway:
“Appeals Pending, But Compliance Can’t Wait – Refunds Must Flow Without Delay.”




