Case Title: Commissioner of CGST, ST & Central Excise v. Cea Raj Constructions
Court: High Court of Bombay
Petition Number: Central Excise Appeal (L) No. 15 of 2018, Notice of Motion No. 165 of 2018
Category of Dispute: Appeal Maintainability (Revenue Threshold)
Date of Judgement: 24 August 2018
Relevant Sections: Section 35R of the Central Excise Act, 1944
Instructions Referred: CBIC Instruction F. No. 390/MISC/116-2017-JC dated 11-07-2018
Facts of the Case [Para 1–4]:
- The revenue had filed an appeal under Section 35G of the Central Excise Act, 1944, challenging the order dated 11 August 2017 passed by the CESTAT.
- An application for condonation of delay in filing the appeal was submitted along with the appeal.
- During the hearing, counsel for the department (Ms. Neha Mehta) submitted that she had received instructions to withdraw the appeal.
- These instructions were based on the CBIC circular dated 11 July 2018, which directed that no appeals be filed or continued where the tax effect was less than ₹50 lakhs. In this case, the tax effect was below that threshold.
Question(s) in Consideration [Para 5]:
- Whether the revenue’s appeal could be entertained when the tax effect was less than ₹50 lakhs in light of the binding instruction issued by CBIC?
Observation of the Court [Para 5]:
- The High Court acknowledged the binding nature of the CBIC instruction dated 11 July 2018 and noted that even if the appeal were restored, it would ultimately have to be withdrawn in compliance with the circular.
Judgement of the Court [Para 5]:
- The court allowed the department’s request and dismissed the appeal as withdrawn, thereby ruling in favour of the assessee.
Between Fine Lines:
- The Bombay High Court reiterated that departmental appeals must follow CBIC instructions limiting litigation based on the monetary threshold.
- Appeals with tax effect below ₹50 lakhs are not maintainable unless exceptions apply.
- Revenue officers are bound by CBIC circulars and must act accordingly.
- This policy aims to reduce litigation burden and focus on high-stake matters.
- The case underlines procedural compliance over contesting low-revenue cases.
Summary of Referred Cases:
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| CBIC Instruction | F. No. 390/MISC/116-2017-JC, dated 11-07-2018 | Directs that no appeal shall be filed or continued by the department before High Courts where the tax effect is less than ₹50 lakhs | Binding on revenue; appeal to be withdrawn |
Takeaway:
“Monetary Limit Trumps Appeal: Revenue Bound by Its Own Circular”




