Case Title: Mahmmadbhai Pirabhai Sadhriyat v. Union of India
Court: High Court of Gujarat
Petition No.: Special Civil Application Nos. 18934, 19045 and 19047 of 2019
Relevant Section: Section 107 of the CGST Act, 2017
Category of Dispute: Confiscation of Conveyance – Jurisdiction & Natural Justice
Date of Judgment: 28 November 2019
Relevant Law: Article 226 of Constitution of India, Section 107 of CGST Act, 2017
Facts of the Case [¶1–2, ¶6]
- The petitioners challenged the common Order-in-Original dated 01.11.2019 passed by the Additional Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise, Vadodara-II, which ordered the confiscation of Eicher trucks and offered redemption on payment of fine. [¶1]
- Petitioners claimed the order lacked reasoning and was issued without jurisdiction, thus violating the principles of natural justice. [¶4]
- The vehicles were initially seized during a search on 17.01.2019, and summons were issued to registered owners but returned undelivered. Later, petitioners appeared before the adjudicating authority upon notice and made submissions. [¶6]
Question(s) in Consideration [¶3, ¶4, ¶5]
- Whether the writ petition under Article 226 is maintainable when an alternate statutory remedy of appeal under Section 107 of the CGST Act exists?
- Whether the Order-in-Original suffers from breach of natural justice or is a non-speaking order?
Observation of Court [¶5–9]
- The Court held that the order was passed under CGST Act, and jurisdiction of adjudicating authority was not in question. Thus, maintainability must meet exceptions recognized by law. [¶5]
- The principles of natural justice were not violated: Show cause notice was issued, petitioners were served and appeared for personal hearing. [¶6]
- The order was not a non-speaking order; reasons were present and the decision cited by petitioners (India Logistics & Cargo Movers v. State of Gujarat) was distinguishable. [¶7]
- Referring to CIT v. Chhabil Dass Agarwal, the Court reiterated that writ jurisdiction under Article 226 cannot be invoked where efficacious alternative remedies are available unless exceptional grounds exist. [¶8]
Judgment of the Court [¶9–11]
- The petitions were dismissed as not maintainable, given the availability of alternate statutory remedy under Section 107 CGST Act. [¶11]
- The Court clarified that the merits of the order were not examined, and the appellate authority must independently adjudicate any appeal filed by the petitioners. [¶10]
Between Fine Lines
This case reinforces that writ petitions under Article 226 are not maintainable when a statutory remedy of appeal exists under the GST Act. Even when allegations of unreasoned or unjust orders are made, unless there is clear violation of natural justice or jurisdiction, the High Court will not entertain such petitions. Proper appeal must be filed before Commissioner (Appeals).
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| India Logistics & Cargo Movers v. State of Gujarat | [2019] 110 taxmann.com 454/76 GST 461 | Held that absence of reasons in confiscation order violates natural justice, making it unsustainable. | Distinguished; Not applicable here |
| CIT v. Chhabil Dass Agarwal | [2013] 36 taxmann.com 36/217 Taxman 143 | Reaffirmed that writs under Article 226 not maintainable when alternate statutory remedies exist. | Followed; applied to dismiss writ |
Takeaway of the Case:
“Writ Route Blocked: Statutory Appeal is the Way in GST Confiscation Orders”




