Home Case Laws Detention of vehicle and goods on the ground of non-filing of Part-B...

Detention of vehicle and goods on the ground of non-filing of Part-B of E-way bill was not valid if detained within a radius of 50 kms.

0
524

Case Title: Rivigo Services (P.) Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh

Court: High Court of Allahabad

Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 689 of 2018

Relevant Sections: Section 129(1) and 129(3) of the CGST Act

Category of Dispute: E-Way Bill – Detention and Penalty

Date of Judgement: April 24, 2018

Relevant Provisions: Rule 138 of CGST Rules, 2017 (as amended by Notification No. 12/2018); UPGST Rules (14th Amendment); Press Release dated 31.03.2018

 

Facts of the Case:

  1. The petitioner, Rivigo Services Pvt. Ltd., is a registered transporter under GST with a branch in Greater Noida, U.P., used for transshipment of goods (Para 3).
  2. The consignor, M/s Paharpur 3P, shipped goods from Sahibabad (Ghaziabad) to consignees in Telangana and Dehradun, generating national e-way bills on 15.04.2018 (Para 3).
  3. Part A of the e-way bills was filled by the consignor; Part B (vehicle details) was left blank to be filled later at the transshipment point by the transporter (Para 6).
  4. While transporting goods from the consignor’s premises to the transshipment hub (~25–30 km), the truck was intercepted by the Mobile Squad of the Commercial Tax Department due to non-filling of Part B of the e-way bill (Para 7).
  5. Detention and seizure orders were passed on 16.04.2018 under Section 129(1), and penalty notice under Section 129(3) demanding 18% tax (Rs. 1,54,792/-) (Para 7-8).

 

Questions in Consideration:

  1. Whether the seizure and penalty were justified when Part B of the e-way bill was not filled during movement within 50 km for transshipment? (Para 9)
  2. Whether the provisions of Rule 138(3) as amended, exempted such short-distance movement from requiring vehicle details in Part B? (Para 9)

 

Observation of the Court:

  1. The Court acknowledged that as per Rule 138(3) (third proviso), if goods are moved within 50 km for transshipment, Part B need not be filled (Para 9).
  2. It relied on the Press Information Bureau clarification dated 31.03.2018, which permits updating Part B during transshipment, and starting e-way bill validity only after such update (Para 11-12).
  3. It found no dispute on generation of valid e-way bills and held that prior to reloading, vehicle details are logically unavailable to the transporter or consignor (Para 12).
  4. The authority’s objections were found unsustainable and without basis to disbelieve petitioner’s explanation (Para 13).

 

Judgement of the Court:

The seizure order dated 16.04.2018 under Section 129(1) and penalty notice under Section 129(3) were set aside. The Court ordered the release of goods and vehicle upon furnishing of indemnity bond equal to the proposed tax and penalty. The writ petition was allowed (Para 14).

 

Between Fine Lines (Simple Summary):

  • Movement of goods for less than 50 km to a transporter’s godown before final dispatch doesn’t need vehicle details in Part B of e-way bill.
  • Transporter can update Part B after reloading for further journey.
  • Seizure for non-filling Part B during such internal movement is invalid.
  • Clarification by the Ministry of Finance supports this interpretation.
  • Court ordered release of goods and struck down the penalty.

Summary of Referred Cases

Name Citation Summary Verdict
Press Information Bureau Clarification PIB Release, 31.03.2018, Ministry of Finance Clarified that for inter-state transport involving transshipment, Part B of the e-way bill can be updated later by the subsequent transporter. Validity starts after Part B is filled. Accepted and relied upon by the Court to interpret Rule 138 fairly

 

LEAVE A REPLY