Home Case Laws Department cannot detain vehicle and goods on the ground that goods were...

Department cannot detain vehicle and goods on the ground that goods were not accompanied with transaction declaration form.

0
463

Case Title: Super India (Global) Logistics Ltd. v. State of U.P.

Court: High Court of Allahabad

Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 686 of 2018

Category of Dispute: Detention of Goods during Transit – E-Way Bill Compliance

Date of Judgement: April 24, 2018

Relevant Sections: Section 129(1) & 129(3) of the U.P. GST Act, 2017

Takeaway: Absence of TDF Cannot Override E-Way Bill Compliance under Inter-State Movement

 

 

Facts of the Case (¶2–4):

  • The petitioner, Super India (Global) Logistics Ltd., a registered dealer (GSTIN: 23AAACJ1657R1Z9), transported 1936 units of biscuits from Gwalior (MP) to Zirakapur (Punjab) for another registered dealer (GSTIN: 03AABCB2066P1ZP).
  • The goods were accompanied by a valid E-way Bill (valid till 28.03.2018) and requisite documents, but not the Transaction Declaration Form (TDF).
  • While transiting through U.P. (Agra), the vehicle was intercepted on 23.03.2018 and seized under Section 129(1) citing lack of TDF, even though physical verification showed no discrepancy in goods. A notice under Section 129(3) was issued the same day.

 

Questions in Consideration (¶3, ¶5):

  • Whether seizure of goods and vehicle solely due to absence of TDF, despite valid E-way Bill and other documents, is lawful?
  • Does the amended GST regime still mandate submission of TDF for inter-state movement?

Observations of the Court (¶6–7):

  • The Court referred to its earlier ruling in Satyendra Goods Transport Corpn. v. State of U.P., which held that valid E-way Bill and tax invoices for inter-state trade eliminate the need for TDF.
  • It agreed that since both consignor and consignee were registered, the IGST liability would be assessed at the destination. No intent to evade tax was evident.
  • Held that the State Government’s prior notification requiring TDF under Rule 138 stood overridden by subsequent Central Government notifications adopting the E-way Bill system (post 01.02.2018).

Judgement of the Court (¶7–8):

  • The seizure order dated 24.03.2018 and penalty notice under Section 129(3) were declared illegal and quashed.
  • Ordered immediate release of goods and vehicle upon submission of the certified order copy.
  • Writ petition allowed. No order as to costs.

Between Fine Lines:

  1. GST authorities cannot seize goods in transit merely due to absence of a TDF if a valid E-way Bill exists.
  2. Interstate consignments accompanied by valid documents are presumed tax-compliant unless proven otherwise.
  3. Notifications inconsistent with the Central E-Way Bill framework stand overridden.
  4. Physical verification without discrepancies negates grounds for seizure.
  5. The ruling reinforces that procedural lapses without tax evasion intent should not lead to penal consequences.

Summary of Referred Cases:

Name Citation Summary Verdict
Satyendra Goods Transport Corpn. v. State of U.P. [2018] 92 taxmann.com 209 / 67 GST 530 Goods moved inter-state with valid invoice and E-way Bill; no evasion of tax evident; TDF not required Seizure was held illegal; relief granted

 

LEAVE A REPLY