Case Title: Super India (Global) Logistics Ltd. v. State of U.P.
Court: High Court of Allahabad
Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 686 of 2018
Category of Dispute: Detention of Goods during Transit – E-Way Bill Compliance
Date of Judgement: April 24, 2018
Relevant Sections: Section 129(1) & 129(3) of the U.P. GST Act, 2017
Takeaway: Absence of TDF Cannot Override E-Way Bill Compliance under Inter-State Movement
Facts of the Case (¶2–4):
- The petitioner, Super India (Global) Logistics Ltd., a registered dealer (GSTIN: 23AAACJ1657R1Z9), transported 1936 units of biscuits from Gwalior (MP) to Zirakapur (Punjab) for another registered dealer (GSTIN: 03AABCB2066P1ZP).
- The goods were accompanied by a valid E-way Bill (valid till 28.03.2018) and requisite documents, but not the Transaction Declaration Form (TDF).
- While transiting through U.P. (Agra), the vehicle was intercepted on 23.03.2018 and seized under Section 129(1) citing lack of TDF, even though physical verification showed no discrepancy in goods. A notice under Section 129(3) was issued the same day.
Questions in Consideration (¶3, ¶5):
- Whether seizure of goods and vehicle solely due to absence of TDF, despite valid E-way Bill and other documents, is lawful?
- Does the amended GST regime still mandate submission of TDF for inter-state movement?
Observations of the Court (¶6–7):
- The Court referred to its earlier ruling in Satyendra Goods Transport Corpn. v. State of U.P., which held that valid E-way Bill and tax invoices for inter-state trade eliminate the need for TDF.
- It agreed that since both consignor and consignee were registered, the IGST liability would be assessed at the destination. No intent to evade tax was evident.
- Held that the State Government’s prior notification requiring TDF under Rule 138 stood overridden by subsequent Central Government notifications adopting the E-way Bill system (post 01.02.2018).
Judgement of the Court (¶7–8):
- The seizure order dated 24.03.2018 and penalty notice under Section 129(3) were declared illegal and quashed.
- Ordered immediate release of goods and vehicle upon submission of the certified order copy.
- Writ petition allowed. No order as to costs.
Between Fine Lines:
- GST authorities cannot seize goods in transit merely due to absence of a TDF if a valid E-way Bill exists.
- Interstate consignments accompanied by valid documents are presumed tax-compliant unless proven otherwise.
- Notifications inconsistent with the Central E-Way Bill framework stand overridden.
- Physical verification without discrepancies negates grounds for seizure.
- The ruling reinforces that procedural lapses without tax evasion intent should not lead to penal consequences.
Summary of Referred Cases:
| Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Satyendra Goods Transport Corpn. v. State of U.P. | [2018] 92 taxmann.com 209 / 67 GST 530 | Goods moved inter-state with valid invoice and E-way Bill; no evasion of tax evident; TDF not required | Seizure was held illegal; relief granted |




