Case Title: M/s OSR Creation vs. State of U.P. and Others
Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
Petition Number: Writ Tax No. 1914 of 2024
Category of Dispute: Penalty under Section 129 – E-Way Bill Discrepancy
Date of Judgement: 27 January 2025
Relevant Section: Section 129 of the CGST Act, 2017
Facts of the Case
(Refer ¶2 to ¶4)
-
The petitioner, a proprietorship based in East Delhi, was engaged in manufacturing and trading furniture.
-
On 21.11.2022, goods were sold to Lotus Herbal Pvt. Ltd., Noida. Though tax invoice and GR were prepared, the e-way bill was not generated initially due to a technical glitch.
-
Given the urgency at the buyer’s end, goods were dispatched with instructions not to cross into U.P. without an e-way bill.
-
The e-way bill was subsequently generated at 4:59 PM on the same day. However, the goods were intercepted and detained by respondent no. 3 at 6:00 PM.
-
The e-way bill was presented before the seizure order was issued. Despite this, a penalty order was issued on 22.11.2022 and confirmed in appeal on 09.08.2023.
Questions in Consideration
(Refer ¶3 and ¶7)
-
Whether penalty under Section 129 of the CGST Act is justified when the e-way bill is produced before the seizure order.
-
Whether mere non-carriage of an e-way bill at interception, without intent to evade tax, constitutes a valid ground for penalty.
Observations of the Court
(Refer ¶8 to ¶13)
-
The goods were intercepted before the e-way bill was physically produced, but the document was submitted with the reply to the show cause notice before the seizure order.
-
Authorities never questioned the genuineness or content of the e-way bill.
-
No finding was recorded that the petitioner intended to evade tax.
-
Court relied on precedent in M/s Bans Steel vs. State of U.P. where similar facts led to quashing of penalty.
-
The Court distinguished M/s Akhilesh Traders vs. State of U.P., as in that case, no documents were presented at any stage before the order.
Judgment of the Court
(Refer ¶14 to ¶16)
-
The Court quashed both orders dated 22.11.2022 and 09.08.2023.
-
It held that since the e-way bill was produced before the seizure order and no malafide intent was established, penalty under Section 129 was unjustified.
-
The writ petition was allowed, and any deposited amount was ordered to be refunded in accordance with the law.
🧾 Between Fine Lines
-
If an e-way bill is produced before seizure, penalty cannot be mechanically imposed.
-
No tax evasion intent = no justification for penalty under Section 129.
-
Authorities must assess intent, not just procedural lapses.
-
Courts will quash penalty if compliance is shown before seizure order.
-
Technical glitches, when promptly rectified, are not tax evasion.
📘 Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| M/s Bans Steel v. State of U.P. | 2024:AHC:129150 | E-way bill submitted before seizure order; no discrepancy found; no intention to evade tax | Penalty quashed |
| M/s Akhilesh Traders v. State of U.P. | 2024:AHC:29040 | No documents produced at interception or before seizure | Penalty upheld |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




