Home Case Laws GST assessment order set aside and remanded as service of notices only...

GST assessment order set aside and remanded as service of notices only on GST portal violated natural justice; fresh hearing allowed on payment of 25% of disputed tax

0
276

Case Title: Kurugondla Sindhu vs. Assistant Commissioner & Ors.
Court: Madras High Court
Petition No.: W.P. No. 2066 of 2025 and W.M.P. Nos. 2417 & 2418 of 2025
Judgment Date: 27.01.2025
Category: Assessment Order – Violation of Principles of Natural Justice
Relevant Sections: Section 73, Section 75(4) of the CGST Act, 2017; Rule 142(1)(a) of the CGST Rules, 2017

Facts (Paras 2–3)

The petitioner, a proprietrix engaged in renting immovable property and registered under GST, duly filed returns and paid taxes for FY 2017–18. Upon scrutiny, the department alleged discrepancies between GSTR-3B and Form 26AS, issuing ASMT-10 on 03.07.2023 and DRC-01 on 04.08.2023. Though a personal hearing was scheduled for 10.08.2023, the petitioner neither replied nor attended. Consequently, an assessment order dated 10.10.2023 was passed confirming the proposed demand.

The petitioner challenged the order on the ground that the notices and order were merely uploaded on the GST portal and not served through registered post or tendered in person, resulting in a denial of opportunity to defend. The petitioner had already remitted over 75% of the disputed tax and sought a remand citing the precedent in M/s. K. Balakrishnan (Balu Cables) v. Asst. Commissioner of GST & CE (W.P.(MD) No. 11924 of 2024, dated 10.06.2024).


Questions before the Court

Whether the assessment order passed solely based on portal-based service of notice without physical or acknowledged delivery constitutes violation of principles of natural justice, warranting interference and remand.


Observations (Paras 4–5)

The Court observed that the petitioner was indeed deprived of effective participation due to lack of proper service of notice. It noted that the department failed to comply with the procedural mandate under Section 75(4), which obligates granting reasonable opportunity of hearing before passing an adverse order. The judgment in M/s. K. Balakrishnan (Balu Cables) was cited, where similar portal-based notice service was held insufficient and the matter was remanded subject to part payment.


Judgment (Paras 5–6)

The Madras High Court set aside the assessment order dated 10.10.2023 and issued detailed directions:

  1. Petitioner to deposit 25% of the disputed tax within 4 weeks.

  2. Any earlier payments or recoveries shall be adjusted toward this 25%.

  3. Upon such compliance, bank and property attachments (DRC-13 and DRC-16) shall be lifted/withdrawn.

  4. The impugned order shall be treated as a show cause notice, and petitioner shall submit objections within 4 weeks.

  5. The assessing authority shall provide a personal hearing and pass a fresh order in accordance with law.

  6. Failure to deposit the 25% or file objections within time would restore the impugned order automatically.

No costs were awarded.


Summary of Cases Referred

Case Name Citation/Reference Ratio Decidendi Outcome
M/s. K. Balakrishnan (Balu Cables) v. O/o. Asst. Commissioner of GST & CE W.P.(MD) No. 11924 of 2024, Madras HC, 10.06.2024 Held that notices uploaded only on GST portal without physical service violate natural justice; remand allowed subject to payment of 25% disputed tax. Remanded to authority for fresh adjudication

Between Fine Lines (Trade Takeaway)

This judgment reinforces that mere uploading of notices or orders on the GST portal is not sufficient service when it leads to loss of opportunity for defense. Taxpayers unaware of such digital notices can seek judicial relief by demonstrating lack of due communication. However, courts may condition such relief upon partial payment (25%) to balance revenue interests. The decision highlights the importance for both taxpayers and departments to ensure effective and acknowledged communication in GST adjudication.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

 

LEAVE A REPLY