Home Case Laws GST demand orders remanded as High Court allowed delayed appeal filing subject...

GST demand orders remanded as High Court allowed delayed appeal filing subject to 25% pre-deposit

0
455

Case Title: M/s Thirumalai Balaji Constructions vs The Deputy Commissioner (ST) & Anr
Court: Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
Petition No.: W.P.(MD) Nos.11803 to 11805 of 2025
Date of Judgment: 02.06.2025
Relevant Section: Section 74(1) of the Tamil Nadu GST Act, 2017
Category: Demand Order – Natural Justice – Appeal Delay

Facts (Para 1–3)

M/s Thirumalai Balaji Constructions, engaged in civil construction, was issued three separate demand orders under Section 74(1) of the TNGST Act for FYs 2017–18, 2019–20, and 2020–21, demanding ₹73,81,572, ₹16,24,628, and ₹21,880 respectively along with interest and penalty. The petitioner contended that the impugned orders dated 30.09.2024 were arbitrary and in violation of principles of natural justice.
Despite having a statutory right of appeal before the Appellate Deputy Commissioner (ADC), the petitioner failed to file the same within the 90-day limitation period and instead approached the High Court through writ petitions.


Questions / Issues (Para 2–3)

Whether the writ petitions could be entertained despite the expiry of limitation for filing appeals under Section 107 of the GST Act, and whether any equitable relief could be extended to the petitioner for pursuing statutory remedies.


Observations (Para 3–5)

The Court noted that while the Supreme Court has consistently held that writ petitions filed after expiry of limitation are not maintainable, the Madras High Court has adopted a consistent approach of permitting appellants to pursue appeals subject to a 25% pre-deposit of the disputed tax.
Justice C. Saravanan reiterated that this pragmatic approach helps balance procedural delay with the taxpayer’s right to be heard. Considering that the petitioner’s registration had been cancelled, the Court directed that physical filing of appeals be allowed before the Appellate Commissioner, who must decide the case on merits without reference to limitation and preferably within three months.


Judgment / Verdict (Para 4–6)

The writ petitions were disposed of with the following directions:

  1. The petitioner is permitted to file statutory appeals within 30 days from receipt of the order.

  2. The appeals will be entertained only upon deposit of 25% of the disputed tax either in cash or by demand draft.

  3. The Appellate Commissioner shall adjudicate the appeals on merits, without reference to limitation, within three months from the date of numbering the appeals.

  4. No costs were awarded, and all connected miscellaneous petitions were closed.


Table: Summary of Related/Similar Cases

Case Court Year Verdict
K. Ramesh vs STO, Madurai Madras HC 2024 Delay in appeal condoned subject to 25% pre-deposit as a condition precedent.
Sree Gokulam Traders vs AC (ST) Madras HC 2023 Allowed appeal filing beyond limitation with pre-deposit due to procedural lapse.
M/s. Tvl. Rajarajeswari Textiles vs DC (ST) Madras HC 2022 Held that delay in appeal filing under Section 107 can be condoned if taxpayer shows bona fide cause and deposits 25%.

Between Fine Lines

This judgment reiterates the High Court’s pragmatic stance towards delayed GST appeals—while procedural deadlines matter, justice should not be denied if the taxpayer shows bona fide intent. For the trade, this serves as a reminder to file appeals within the statutory time but also provides comfort that limited condonation may be possible through writ jurisdiction, provided a reasonable pre-deposit is made.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY