Case Summary
Case Title: Mahindra & Mahindra Limited v. Union of India & Ors.
Court: High Court of Chhattisgarh, Bilaspur
Petition No.: Writ Appeal No. 172 of 2024 (arising from WPT No. 42 of 2024)
Date of Judgment: 10 April 2024
Coram: Justice Goutam Bhaduri & Justice Radhakishan Agrawal
Category: Principles of Natural Justice – Demand & Recovery under GST
Relevant Sections: Section 73(1), 73(9), 75(4), 75(5) of the CGST Act, 2017
Facts (Paras 1–3, 10–11)
Mahindra & Mahindra Limited, a registered assessee, was served a notice under Section 73(1) of the CGST Act on 29.09.2023 for short/non-payment of tax. The reply was due on 30.10.2023. However, personal hearing was scheduled on 12.10.2023, before the expiry of the reply deadline. The appellant sought extension on 11.10.2023 and again on 25.10.2023. The reply was finally filed on 15.11.2023, reiterating the request for adjournment and meaningful hearing. Despite this, an adverse order dated 29.12.2023 was passed without affording a proper hearing.
The assessee challenged the order under Article 226, contending violation of Section 75(4) & (5), which mandate a meaningful hearing and allow adjournments up to three times. The Single Judge dismissed the writ citing alternate remedy, leading to this appeal.
Questions in Issue (Paras 5–7, 12)
-
Whether fixing personal hearing before the due date of reply violates the mandate of Section 75(4) & (5)?
-
Whether denial of meaningful hearing amounts to breach of natural justice, justifying writ jurisdiction despite alternate remedies?
Observations (Paras 8–16)
-
Section 73(9) requires consideration of representation before determination of tax.
-
Section 75(4) requires hearing where adverse order is contemplated; Section 75(5) permits adjournments up to three times.
-
Fixing hearing before the reply date is procedurally defective, as no assessee can be heard meaningfully without first submitting reply.
-
Hearing must be real, comprehensive and effective, not a mere formality.
-
Reliance was placed on Umanath Pandey v. State of UP (2009) 12 SCC 40, Dharampal Satyapal Ltd. v. CCE (2015) 8 SCC 519, Automotive Tyre Manufacturers Assn. (2011) 2 SCC 258, and Ridge v. Baldwin (1963 AC 40), all emphasizing that audi alteram partem requires notice, adequate time, and oral hearing.
-
The Court stressed that personal hearing is an indispensable facet of adjudication, and statutory procedure cannot be short-circuited.
Judgment (Paras 16–20)
-
The Court held that Section 75(4) was violated as hearing was given prematurely, defeating the purpose of a fair hearing.
-
The Single Judge erred in relegating the assessee to alternate remedy, since violation of natural justice permits direct writ remedy under Article 226, as reiterated in Kalpraj Dharamshi v. Kotak Investment Advisors Ltd. (2021) 10 SCC 401.
-
The impugned order dated 29.12.2023 was set aside.
-
Matter remanded to the Joint Commissioner of State Tax with directions to provide fresh personal hearing on 08.05.2024 in accordance with Section 75(4) & (5).
-
Appeal allowed.
Case Law Table
| Case Referred | Court & Citation | Ratio Decidendi |
|---|---|---|
| Kalpraj Dharamshi v. Kotak Investment Advisors Ltd. (2021) 10 SCC 401 | Supreme Court | Violation of natural justice permits writ jurisdiction under Article 226 despite alternate remedies. |
| Umanath Pandey v. State of UP (2009) 12 SCC 40 | Supreme Court | Notice must be precise, with adequate time to reply; otherwise, order is vitiated. |
| Dharampal Satyapal Ltd. v. CCE (2015) 8 SCC 519 | Supreme Court | Even administrative/quasi-judicial decisions with civil consequences require a fair hearing. |
| Automotive Tyre Manufacturers Assn. v. DA (2011) 2 SCC 258 | Supreme Court | Oral hearing is indispensable; written submissions are no substitute. |
| Ridge v. Baldwin (1963 AC 40) | House of Lords | Natural justice requires unbiased tribunal, notice of charges, and fair hearing. |
| Fino Paytech Ltd. v. UOI, WP No. 8965/2023 (Bom HC) | Bombay HC | Hearing under Section 75 CGST Act is mandatory; cannot be bypassed. |
| MS KEC International Ltd. v. UOI (2024 (2) TMI 359) | Allahabad HC | Adverse order without meaningful hearing violates Section 75 and natural justice. |
Between Fine Lines
This ruling underscores that GST adjudication must follow meaningful hearing procedures. Fixing personal hearing before the reply deadline or treating it as a mere formality is impermissible. Businesses can directly approach High Courts under Article 226 if natural justice is breached, without being forced into statutory appeals. For trade, this judgment is a safeguard ensuring that GST authorities provide fair opportunity before imposing demands.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




