Home Case Laws Refund appeals dismissed as clause 5 of Notification No. 53/2023 was upheld;...

Refund appeals dismissed as clause 5 of Notification No. 53/2023 was upheld; Court held limitation applies and notification cannot be struck down merely for being unfavourable

0
335

Case: Bharat Aluminium Company Limited v. Union of India & Others

Court: High Court of Chhattisgarh, Bilaspur
Petition Numbers: WPT No. 53 of 2024 and connected matters (54–65 of 2024)
Category of Dispute: Refund of Input Tax Credit – Limitation & validity of notification clause
Date of Judgement: 09.04.2024
Relevant Sections:

  • Section 107(1) & (4) of the CGST Act, 2017

  • Section 54 of the CGST Act, 2017

  • Section 16 of the IGST Act, 2017

  • Section 8 & 9(2) of the GST (Compensation to States) Act, 2017

  • Notification No. 53/2023–Central Tax dated 02.11.2023 (Clause 5)

Facts (Paras 3–8, 14–17)

Bharat Aluminium Company Limited (BALCO) manufactures aluminium using electricity generated in its captive power plants (CPPs). The company pays GST Compensation Cess on coal purchases. Since aluminium is exported, BALCO claimed refund of unutilised ITC of compensation cess under Section 54 of the CGST Act read with Section 16 of the IGST Act.

Refund applications were partly rejected by the Assistant Commissioner (State Tax) on the ground that electricity supplied to the staff township was not in the course of business. Orders were uploaded on the GST portal in 2021–22 but were physically received only on 07.08.2023. BALCO filed appeals in September 2023, within three months of receipt of physical orders. However, the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) dismissed the appeals on 05.12.2023 citing limitation under Section 107 CGST Act and reliance on Clause 5 of Notification No. 53/2023, which excludes appeals “not involving tax demand.”

BALCO challenged both the rejection orders and the constitutional validity of Clause 5, contending that it was arbitrary, discriminatory, and violative of Article 14, as refund-related appeals were excluded from the benefit of extended timelines provided under Notification No. 53/2023.


Questions Before Court (Paras 18–20)

  1. Whether the rejection of refund appeals by the appellate authority on the ground of limitation was valid in law?

  2. Whether Clause 5 of Notification No. 53/2023–Central Tax, which excludes appeals “not involving tax demand,” is arbitrary and unconstitutional under Article 14?

  3. Whether the petitioner could seek condonation of delay given the orders were not “communicated” in time?


Observations (Paras 21–23)

  • The Notification No. 53/2023 was issued to provide a special window for taxpayers whose appeals were time-barred due to delays in communication of orders uploaded on GSTN. However, Clause 5 clearly restricted its scope only to cases “involving tax demand.”

  • The petitioner’s case related to refund of unutilised ITC, not tax demand, hence excluded from the benefit of extension.

  • The appellate authority had rightly dismissed the appeals as being time-barred by over a year. The term “communicated” under Section 107 was interpreted to mean that mere uploading on the GST portal is valid, and waiting for physical copies cannot justify condonation beyond statutory limits.

  • A clause of a notification cannot be struck down merely because it is not beneficial to one class of taxpayers. Classification between demand-related and refund-related appeals was held to have rational nexus with legislative intent.


Judgement (Paras 23–24, Headnote)

  • The High Court dismissed all writ petitions.

  • Clause 5 of Notification No. 53/2023 was upheld as valid.

  • The refund appeals filed by BALCO were held barred by limitation.

  • Petitioners were granted liberty to approach the Appellate Tribunal (once constituted) or a Single Judge for further remedies.

Headnote: A clause of a notification cannot be declared ultra vires merely because it is not beneficial to a party or is intended to bypass a statutory remedy.


Table of Cases Referred

Case Citation Ratio / Relevance
Union of India v. N.S. Rathnam & Sons (2015) 10 SCC 681 Classification must have rational nexus with object; Article 14 forbids hostile discrimination
Bhavnagar University v. Palitana Sugar Mills (2003) 2 SCC 111 Beneficial legislation should be liberally construed
Arvind Gupta v. Assistant Commissioner of State Taxes (Calcutta HC) WPA No. 2903 of 2024 Delay in filing GST appeals and condonation discussed

Between Fine Lines

For industry, the ruling clarifies that refund-related appeals (e.g., against rejection of ITC refund) cannot claim benefit of extended timelines under Notification No. 53/2023. Taxpayers must be vigilant about orders uploaded on the GST portal, as uploading itself may be treated as communication for limitation purposes. Relief is limited to demand-related disputes, and refund-related litigants will have to pursue remedies strictly within statutory time frames.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY