Home Case Laws GST demand stayed as Orissa High Court applies 10% pre-deposit rule in...

GST demand stayed as Orissa High Court applies 10% pre-deposit rule in absence of Tribunal

0
334

Case Title: M/s. Debashis Kumar Panda v. Joint Commissioner of State Tax (Appeal), CT & GST, Sambalpur and others
Court: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Petition No.: WP(C) No. 147 of 2025
Category: Appeal under GST – Stay on demand during pendency before unconstituted Tribunal
Date of Judgment: 07 January 2025
Relevant Section: Section 112 of the CGST Act, 2017 (Appeal to Appellate Tribunal)
Related Category: Stay of demand during interim period due to non-constitution of Tribunal


Facts (Para 1-3):

The petitioner, M/s. Debashis Kumar Panda, challenged the order dated 31 October 2023 passed by the First Appellate Authority under the Odisha GST Act. The assessee intended to appeal before the GST Appellate Tribunal, but since the Tribunal had not yet been constituted, the petitioner invoked writ jurisdiction before the High Court seeking protection against coercive recovery.
Counsel relied on the precedent set in M/s. Maa Tarini Traders v. State of Odisha and others (WP(C) No. 42015 of 2023, order dated 16 February 2024), wherein the Court had granted stay on condition of deposit of 10% of disputed tax at appeal filing and further 20% of the remaining disputed tax for stay of recovery.


Questions before the Court (Para 2-3):

Whether the petitioner is entitled to stay on the impugned demand order by depositing only 10% of the remaining disputed tax, in view of subsequent notifications reducing the pre-deposit percentage, and in line with the earlier Division Bench directions pending constitution of the GST Tribunal.


Court’s Observations (Para 3-5):

The Bench comprising Justice Arindam Sinha and Justice M.S. Sahoo observed that after the Maa Tarini Traders ruling, the Central Government issued a notification dated 16 August 2024 reducing the mandatory pre-deposit for stay of recovery to 10%. The State of Odisha correspondingly notified the same on 29 October 2024. Therefore, the Court accepted the petitioner’s plea that the revised rate of 10% should apply in the present case as well.


Judgment (Para 5-6):

The High Court directed that the impugned appellate order shall remain stayed upon the petitioner depositing 10% of the disputed tax as per the latest notification. The writ petition was accordingly disposed of, following the ratio of Maa Tarini Traders with modification to the quantum of pre-deposit.


Summary of referred case

Case Name Court Decision Verdict Summary
M/s. Maa Tarini Traders v. State of Odisha and others (WP(C) No. 42015 of 2023) Orissa High Court 16 Feb 2024 Tribunal not constituted; recovery stayed if 10% of disputed tax deposited at appeal filing and further 20% of remaining disputed tax for stay.

Between Fine Lines:

This ruling further harmonizes state practice with the Central GST framework, ensuring taxpayers are not prejudiced by the non-constitution of the Appellate Tribunal. For trade and industry, it provides continued relief from recovery proceedings on payment of 10% of disputed tax, streamlining interim protection and maintaining parity with Central notifications.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY