Case Title: M/s. Coastal Construction v. Chief Commissioner of CT & GST, Cuttack & Others
Court: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Petition Number: W.P.(C) No. 31658 of 2024
Date of Judgment/Order: 03 January 2025
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC) — Wrongful Reversal & Procedural Error
Relevant Section: Section 73 and Section 16(2) of the Odisha GST Act, 2017 (pari materia with CGST Act, 2017)
Facts (Para 1–2)
The petitioner, M/s. Coastal Construction, challenged a show cause notice (SCN) dated 8 August 2023 issued under Section 73 of the Odisha GST Act for FY 2017-18. The SCN alleged wrongful availment of ITC of ₹ 37,02,723/-, calculated as 18% of ₹ 2,05,70,686/- shown as sundry creditors in the books of accounts. The petitioner argued that the authority wrongly quoted Section 16(2) by inserting a non-existent clause (e) — a clear typographical error — and that the demand was mechanically confirmed by the order dated 12 December 2023 without due application of mind.
The petitioner further explained that the sum of ₹ 2,05,70,686/- included exempted supplies (diesel and services from unregistered suppliers) and only ₹ 30,38,928/- related to taxable supplies. The alleged ITC difference of ₹ 6,63,795/- arose merely from accounting classification, not wrongful availment.
Questions Before the Court
-
Whether a show cause notice citing a non-existent clause (e) under Section 16(2) of OGST Act renders the subsequent demand order invalid.
-
Whether the petitioner is entitled to stay of demand where the ITC computation and legal basis in the SCN are patently erroneous.
Observations (Para 3–5)
The Court noted that the Revenue alleged wrongful ITC availment of ₹ 37,02,723/-, while the petitioner accounted for ₹ 30,38,928/- as valid taxable supplies. The difference of ₹ 6,63,795/- required factual reconciliation.
The Bench acknowledged that insertion of clause (e) in Section 16(2) in the SCN and impugned order was a typographical error since only two provisos follow clause (d). The Court observed that this raised prima facie doubt about the correctness of the adjudication process.
Revenue counsel contended that non-payment to creditors within 180 days under Section 16(2)(d) warranted reversal of ITC and that the order was appealable. However, the Bench emphasized that procedural and substantive satisfaction regarding availment and reversal of ITC must be demonstrated.
Judgment (Para 5–6)
The Hon’ble Court held that the erroneous inclusion of clause (e) constituted a typographical and legal error in the SCN and order, warranting further examination. Accordingly, the Court directed the Revenue to issue proper instructions and ordered that the impugned order shall remain stayed until the next hearing (21 January 2025).
This interim protection ensures that no recovery is initiated pending correction of the procedural defect and factual verification of ITC availment.
Summary of Referred Principles
| Case/Principle | Issue | Verdict / Ratio |
|---|---|---|
| Section 16(2) of CGST/OGST Act | Availment of ITC subject to payment within 180 days | Typographical addition of clause (e) renders the notice legally flawed |
| Section 73 of CGST/OGST Act | Determination of tax not paid or wrongly availed | Requires accurate legal basis and opportunity of hearing before confirmation |
Between Fine Lines
For taxpayers, this ruling underscores that even a typographical or misquoted section in a GST show cause notice can vitiate proceedings if it leads to wrong legal inference. Authorities must ensure statutory precision and verify the factual basis before alleging ITC reversal. Dealers should promptly challenge such notices citing procedural infirmity and seek stay till correction.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




